Yann Lecun is a legend, no doubt, but, his critique is starting to become outdated. He wants the whole world to slow down and wait for his preferred paradigm, but everyone is out shipping instead. We have LLMs that pass BAR exams now and do multi-step "reasoning".
I am an LLM reasoning skeptic too, but the problem is, he's dismissing real measurable progress while not proving his own alternative approach.
He's starting to sound the like stochastic parrot crowd, shaking fists from the side line while everyone and their dog throws these systems into a pot and sees what they can cook up.
I am an LLM reasoning skeptic too, but the problem is, he's dismissing real measurable progress while not proving his own alternative approach.
Instead, he should spend long days working to prove his contrarian hypothesis.