30 comments

  • ninjaranter 1 hour ago
    A comment complaining this was obviously written by an AI, and the standard template is a tell. A philosophical observation about what that says about the state on online discourse. Link to the Dead Internet Wikipedia page.
    • Mordisquitos 1 hour ago
      A response appreciating the comment above for saving ones time.
      • tsumnia 13 minutes ago
        A bad faith response that attempts to derail the conversation from the original article.
    • seamossfet 34 minutes ago
      This is why I built [AI slop tool]. [Self promotion link to my vibe coded startup with no users]
  • jasong 1 hour ago
    A poor attempt at joining the convo too late because I don't browse /new like everyone else. No one upvotes, and I question my intelligence for the 3rd time today.
    • awkwardpotato 4 minutes ago
      A random reply hours later, long after the post has left the front page
  • joshstrange 1 hour ago
    > Cherry-picked quote from the article cut off too early

    Bad faith argument that could only be made by not reading further into the article or cutting the quote off before it answers the exact question/argument posed here.

    • freehorse 19 minutes ago
      Comment asking the previous commenter in a passive aggressive manner whether they had actually read the article, without providing any further context or counter to the argument made.
  • Eduard 1 hour ago
    A comment at Hacker News which provides a nuanced critique and which gains plenty of upvotes as a lot of users agree to the comment's sentiment.
    • sillysaurusx 56 minutes ago
      A comment disagreeing with the central argument, presenting factual evidence for why it’s mistaken. Downvoted for an hour before balancing back out to a score of 2.
  • zirkonit 1 hour ago
    A comment based on the reading of the title that could only be conceived if the commenter didn't bother to click the article at all.
    • mihaic 1 hour ago
      A snide and vitriolic remark that observes on how the first paragraph actually addresses the concern of the person which hasn't read the article. A further continuation on this being representative of the state of modern online discourse.
  • cperciva 40 minutes ago
    A complaint about the quality of posts and the comments they elicit here, followed by an allegation that Hacker News is turning into Reddit.
  • mellosouls 46 minutes ago
    "A Technical Blog Post by a Big Name Expert" (2013)

    http://bradconte.com/files/misc/HackerNewsParodyThread/

    Discussion (589 points, 189 comments):

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5326511

  • Karrot_Kream 33 minutes ago
    A comment making a subtle point about something discussed in the middle of the article that languishes near the bottom of the page because nobody read the full article.
  • boznz 13 minutes ago
    I guess I am too honest to go down the click-bait title stuff. I would love to get more traffic too my web site, but not this way. I prefer to write up interesting hardware of software projects, but i'm in the middle of writing another sci-fi epic and there are only so many projects you can juggle :-)
  • stevekemp 53 minutes ago
    An obvious attempt to insert a link into my own vibe-coded project, in the pretense it is either relevant or related.
  • econ 30 minutes ago
    Repeat the title 3 times in the first 3 lines then again as the start of the next paragraph.

    Fill the rest of the article assuming this is the readers first day on planet earth. Like, an article about a CPU architecture should start with the early history of mathematics.

  • CephalopodMD 18 minutes ago
    A link to the HN discussion from when this was already posted here 6 months ago, possibly to be helpful, but also possibly as an attempt to admonish others for not knowing this is a repost.
  • ramon156 1 hour ago
    A niche reference almost no one gets, except one.
  • brandonmensing 1 hour ago
    A note of gratitude from a first time poster who tries to take some credit by saying they have always felt the same way
  • saaaaaam 21 minutes ago
    A schtick that is at least as old as the internet, revitalised for new audiences who think it is brilliantly original, to make the author look clever.
  • salomon812 20 minutes ago
    A sentence remarking this concept was implemented in a different media.

    ----

    Title of the song

    Naive expression of love

    Reluctance to accept that you are gone

    Request to turn back time and rectify my wrongs

    Repetition of the title of the song

  • r721 49 minutes ago
    Reminds me of Schizopolis movie (by Steven Soderbergh):

    >Fletcher Munson: [sunnily, on homecoming] Generic greeting!

    >Mrs. Munson: [warmly] Generic greeting returned!

    >[they kiss and chuckle at each other]

    >Fletcher Munson: Imminent sustenance.

    >Mrs. Munson: Overly dramatic statement regarding upcoming meal.

    >Fletcher Munson: Oooh! False reaction indicating hunger and excitement!

    https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0117561/quotes/

  • gabeyaw 1 hour ago
    A question that was addressed in the 3rd paragraph of the article
  • cpfohl 1 hour ago
    Anyone struggle with the large font size? I can only consume about 2 lines, maybe three lines at that size before I struggle with tracking.

    The article itself was in fact delightful once I zoomed out a bunch.

  • Joeboy 53 minutes ago
    An opinion about the design of the website.
    • terramex 31 minutes ago
      Link to HN guidelines with following quote pasted below:

      > Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—e.g. article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting.

      https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

  • nusl 33 minutes ago
    This seems like a useful reference when asking AI to create content for you, despite the irony
  • j2kun 1 hour ago
    A comment not about the article, but rather about the perceived quality of the HN comments.
  • nothinkjustai 8 minutes ago
    A comment pointing out that this submission and/or comment section break the HN rules, which are selectively ignored by the VC mods.
  • mhb 58 minutes ago
    An expression of surprise and appreciation that the author, an expert in his field, is actually a HN participant.
  • seamossfet 39 minutes ago
    A false dichotomy that segments typical replies into one of two groups.

    Group 1: A thinly veiled straw man that buckets everyone I disagree with, along with an attempt to appear as if I'm being unbiased

    Group 2: The group I put myself in and provide better arguments for why this perspective is correct.

    Vague motte and bailey statement that gives me plausible deniability when someone criticizes my analysis.

  • tomi_dev 1 hour ago
    Feels similar with cold email.I used to think it was mostly about better copy or subject lines, but lately it feels like timing matters way more. Same message, different moment, completely different outcome.

    Have you seen cases where timing mattered more than the message itself?

  • wizardforhire 2 hours ago
    A simple statement of acknowledgement.

    > a quote from the article

    A link to something relevant or interesting to add or support a point [1]

    An opinionated comment or personal anecdote.

    [1] the link from above

    • bensyverson 1 hour ago
      A reply which references neither the parent comment nor the article, but makes a strong and likely negative statement.
    • Redster 2 hours ago
      >> a quote from the article

      > An opinionated comment or personal anecdote.

      Counter opinion or added nuance. [1]

      [1] A link for support or to demonstrate a counterexample.

      • zirkonit 1 hour ago
        An uncalled-for ad hominem that serves to quickly devolve the discussion in opinionated ragebait.
  • throwanem 18 minutes ago
    ...sheesh.
  • _doctor_love 1 hour ago
    Tu caca, Derrida?
    • NonHyloMorph 42 minutes ago
      ramon156 12 minutes ago | unvote | prev | next [–]

      A niche reference almost no one gets, except one

      • _doctor_love 31 minutes ago
        An appreciative comment making the original niche poster feel seen.
  • stephbook 1 hour ago
    [dead]