Should you leave red herrings about yourself online?

(blog.alcazarsec.com)

24 points | by alcazar 2 hours ago

12 comments

  • whythismatters 1 minute ago
    This article reminded me of seeing this in GH trending repositories last month: https://github.com/soxoj/maigret

    "For educational and lawful purposes only"

  • nomel 46 minutes ago
    Of course. This was the encouraged behavior in the early 2k. There were little PSA's about it online. You never put your real info online, because there are crazy people out there that will use it.

    I've tried to explain to friends and family that they shouldn't put their first, middle, and last name, all employment info, city, state, etc in their social media bio, and use the same headshot in all their accounts, but they seem to think the sociability/sanity filter that exists in their immediate circle somehow applies to the entire population on the internet.

    • observationist 2 minutes ago
      Crazy people, like Amazon, and Google, and the RNC and DNC think tanks. To maximize the extraction of value from your life, of course. Enjoy the ride.
    • alcazar 33 minutes ago
      The fact that you shouldn't use your real info online is clear to many. That being said, is it better to leave the fields empty, call yourself "anon," or create an imaginary online persona with inaccurate data to throw OSINT investigators off?
    • liotier 40 minutes ago
      Not everyone wants to wear a mask in public. Free speech requires anonymity and pseudonymity to remain a possibility, but most humans are just fine with a single all-purpose identity.
      • nomel 23 minutes ago
        > Not everyone wants to wear a mask in public.

        Yet you'll find exactly nobody walking around, in public, with all of this information on their shirt. People seem to treat the internet as safer than real life public.

  • allthetime 17 minutes ago
    I had the good sense to use a fake name long ago when I first signed up for facebook. A handful of my friends did the same. Over the years it has paid off in terms of people I don't know not being able to look me up. I'm also lucky to have a very common name. I am very un-googlable unless you know actual details about my professional life, in which case you can learn a bit more about what I do for work, but nothing else.

    I also have a secondary facebook account with my real name whose "friends" are only random acquaintances who have bothered trying to connect with me over the years. I have used this in the past when potential employers, or border guards, have asked about my online presence.

    I've been online since I was young and deep dark secrets about me are contained and findable on old forum databases and fragments of lost proto-social networks. I might be over-confident, but I'm almost sure not even palantir knows.

    • NDlurker 9 minutes ago
      All our accounts will eventually be linked by our writing style.

      I love having a really common name. Growing up, my neighbor down the road had the same name and we'd get each other mail sometimes. One time I even met a guy who had the same middle name as me. It's kind of funny, my name is so common you can't find me on Google, and my girlfriend's name is so unique that there's almost 100% certainty that nobody else in the world has her name, so very googleable. I love the anonymity of my common name and she loves the unique identifier that is hers.

  • alcazar 29 minutes ago
    Derek Sivers is of the opinion that a fake persona is better than not sharing any details [1]:

    > Create and post a back-story to answer (instead of avoid) the frequently asked questions.

    1: https://sive.rs/anon

    • renticulous 12 minutes ago
      Noisy signals about tech literate people is still a signal. If only few experts are planting fake data about themselves, companies can cordon you off and spend more resources in deanonymizing you. By muddying the water, you are planting a target on yourself if many others aren't doing it.
  • ofjcihen 54 minutes ago
    I find that at least for the goofy “look up anyone and brace yourself” data hoovering companies having a super common name means my info gets muddled in with a ton of other people’s.

    Everyone legally change their name to the current most common name.

    • alcazar 31 minutes ago
      Being named John Smith is such an underappreciated superpower.
  • jkingsbery 53 minutes ago
    In my experience as a former astronaut, international spy, and traveler to half the countries in the world, the jury is still out.
    • ofjcihen 52 minutes ago
      You too? There’s so many of us I think we’re already lost in the crowd.
  • ungreased0675 34 minutes ago
    Where are some good places to plant false data?

    Insanely attractive people follow me around constantly and I need some more privacy.

    • toast0 26 minutes ago
      I got myself a Pulitzer Prize, which helps a lot. Well ok, the guy who shares my name and writes terrible books managed to get himself a prize, but it really helps with hiding myself in searches. Well that and the Florida man who also shares my name who caught charges for terrible things :(
      • jerf 15 minutes ago
        I remember the distinctly mixed feelings I got in the late 90s to early 2000s watching a search of my real name go from nothing but me, to mostly me, to "hey I'm still in the top 10", to not even on the front page depending on what search engine you use. (I still see myself on Google's front page, but not Bing's. Bing suggests that if I want more information on my real name I should postfix it with the word "fired", so, hey, I guess things could be worse because that's not me....)
  • kotaKat 9 minutes ago
    Depends. Does that include making questionable Google searches about hundreds of different crime plots so that government handlers get super confused later on down the line?

    Gotta make at least one-bank-heist-search a month.

  • dvh 50 minutes ago
    I had to quit Large Penis Club, the parking lots were too small for my automobile.
  • cyanydeez 15 minutes ago
    As a Texan, minority owned business living in alaska using a VPN via the artic circle through the EU GDPR, I think everyone should be their authentic self.
  • josefritzishere 56 minutes ago
    yes.
  • a3abv 32 minutes ago
    Prolific AI blog giving advice about not trying to deceive AI so that AI gets the most pristine and valuable information.