What was a Token Ring network?

(dfarq.homeip.net)

18 points | by ibobev 2 hours ago

7 comments

  • dspillett 14 minutes ago
    > and unlike Ethernet, all the cards on the ring had to talk at the same speed.

    Essentially that was the same for Ethernet too, everything on the same leg needs to talk at the same speed, though IIRC a different speed device wouldn't take down everything, it would just cause a significant excess of collisions due to the out-of-sync cross-talk and not be able to talk to anything itself. It wasn't until switching hubs and full switches were around that you could mix speeds on the same leg (with a switching hub you'd actually have two legs, one at each speed, bridged, with a full switch you have a separate collision domain per port so can mix speeds quite freely).

  • dlinder 36 minutes ago
    Token-passing networks were interesting for hard real time system analysis, as they featured deterministic access control instead of collision detection. They made possible extending Rate Monotonic Scheduling theory to the network layer as well. The priority work (priority ceiling protocol, multi level token priority schemes) survive today in token bucket rate limiting.
  • HarHarVeryFunny 23 minutes ago
    Short version:

    Token Ring was a networking alternative to Ethernet.

    With Ethernet when a node wants to transmit it just does so, then backs off and retries if there was a collision (someone else trying to transmit at the same time).

    Token Ring avoided collisions by passing a "permission to transmit" token from node to node in circular (ring) fashion.

  • blakesterz 28 minutes ago
    The "WAS" in that title just made me feel really old. I remember learning about this in college and it being a thing that I would need to work with and understand how it works why it's different than ethernet. And now it's just a big "WAS".
  • EvanAnderson 45 minutes ago
    My local hospital system (Premier Health) was all-in on IBM and token ring. I remember being chagrined when they built a new hospital in 1998 and wired everything for token ring. The writing was clearly on the wall for token ring by 1998 but their IT department bled IBM blue.

    Fast-forward to 2013, when my wife was giving birth to our daughter in one of their hospitals, and I noticed an unused type-1 token ring wall jack in our room right beside some occupied 8P8C (aka RJ-45) jacks.

  • bharrison 2 hours ago
  • bell-cot 1 hour ago
    Summary: Something that coulda been really cool & awesome, if not for crappy decisions made by the Dark Lord...er, I mean IBM.

    Lot more details: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Token_Ring

    • datakan 51 minutes ago
      Token Ring was always a bad idea, even before IBM screwed it up. Tanium still does this crap and it's awful.