Git for US Legislation

(lexifina.com)

20 points | by alansaber 1 hour ago

4 comments

  • 7kago_yomi 8 minutes ago
    Unlike code, natural language laws have many exceptions and context dependencies, so trying to manage them cleanly with Git seems like it would be tough as data structuring costs and exception handling (hardcode-style responses) increase.
    • JumpCrisscross 5 minutes ago
      > natural language laws have many exceptions and context dependencies

      The complexity is in common law, not natural-language laws.

      The U.S. Code and Code of Federal Regulations can be completely presented through a Git-like system. The complexity comes in when attaching court cases.

  • mushufasa 22 minutes ago
    I'm not an expert in this domain but I'm aware there has been prior work to attempt this. I'd appreciate if someone knowledgeable could post some of that context.
  • infogulch 10 minutes ago
    [dead]
  • octoberfranklin 26 minutes ago
    Fraudulent title, you can't git-clone this.
    • doezi 8 minutes ago
      Not really. It is arguing for version controlled legislation. So who’s responsible for what portions of literal laws and policy. I hope your "not clone-able" is in jest
      • JumpCrisscross 4 minutes ago
        > who’s responsible for what portions of literal laws and policy

        This makes sense for bills. It doesn't for laws. Once a bill is a law, it's the will of the Congress.

        • rileymat2 0 minutes ago
          You could tag yes/no/abstains to it.