I can’t believe it’s 1!

(aperiodical.com)

26 points | by ColinWright 3 days ago

10 comments

  • jeremyscanvic 11 minutes ago
    This is a good opportunity to remind a fun property about decimal expansions (& expansions in other bases). One might intuitively think that real numbers have a unique decimal expansion but the fact that 1.000... = 0.999... disproves it. Still, it's not too difficult to show that every real number admits a unique decimal expansion _unless_ it has one that ends with a sequence of zeros or a sequence of nines. In that case it has exactly two decimal expansions. This shows that 1.000... = 0.999... is the only such quirk, all the other cases are basically the same, 232.128000... = 232.127999... for instance.
  • bemtevi 1 hour ago
    I think the key to this is that one should not look at 0.99999999.... as a regular decimal or a number in itself. Unlike finite decimals like 0.1235, infinitely continuing ones don't have an immediate physical interpretation. 0.9999...is just shorthand for an infinite process that in turn comes about due to the idiosyncracies of allowing infinity in the first place.

    A lot of people just get confused because numbers like 0.23, 0.8, are intuitive and thus something that looks syntactically similar like 0.9999..... also feels like it should be intuitive.

    But it's not. It's just something that crosses the border from the concrete into the much more abstract. Just an infinite process. Just 1.

    • Sharlin 29 minutes ago
      0.9… should not be seen as any kind of process. It’s simply another way of spelling 1, just like 4/6 is another way of spelling 2/3, as is -2/-3. There’s nothing special, mysterious, or non-numeric about it. It’s simply another, redundant encoding of the same number.

      Any place-value numeral is a shorthand for writing a particular geometric series. Only considering numbers between 0 and 1:

        0.abc… = a*10^-1 + b*10^-2 + c*10^-3 + …
      
      If there exists one last nonzero digit in the place-value representation, there is one last nonzero term in the series, and the sum is trivial to compute.

      But if the place-value string is infinite? Well, we know that infinite series can have finite sums, and in particular all of these place-value series converge and have finite sums [exercise: show why].

      Specifically, the sum of a converging infinite series, and thus the value of the corresponding place-value expression, is defined as the limit of its finite prefix sums. The general formula for the sum of a converging geometric series such as 0.9… is

        S = a / (1 - r)
      
      where a is the first term and r the ratio of two consecutive terms. In this case S = 0.9…, a = 0.9 and r = 0.1. So

        0.9… = 0.9 / (1 - 0.1)
      
             = 1
      
      Intuitively, the prefix sums of 0.9… are

        0.9
        0.99
        0.999
        0.9999
        ...
      
      and it’s "clear" that the limit of this sequence at infinity is 1. And because 0.9… is by definition that limit,

        0.9… = 1.
    • unrented7977 52 minutes ago
      Of course infinitely repeating decimals have physical representation. You can take a third of anything and end up with 0.333...%

      Even infinite irrational numbers have physical representation, like pi.

      • tel 44 minutes ago
        Perhaps the act of cutting a quantity into thirds is physically intuitive, but its representation as 0.333... as driven by the infinite series 3/10 + 3/100 + 3/1000 + ... = 1/3 is, to me anyway, less obviously physical.
      • bemtevi 46 minutes ago
        That is true. I should have been more precise and say that the act of continually adding new numbers to the end of a decimal doesn't really.
    • SjokoladeIsHare 1 hour ago
      Helps to think of finite decimals as themselves with infinite zeros afterwards.

      0.23 == 0.23000…

    • noduerme 1 hour ago
      in the gambling world, we'd just say "for all practical purposes"
  • imurray 1 hour ago
    The wikipedia page on the "0.999... = 1" fact is good: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/0.999...

    Discussed April 28, 2020, 626 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23004086

  • jeremyscanvic 24 minutes ago
    That's really cool. Seems to be the case for 0.2468... in "base" 0.3579... as well! I wonder what condition on the base makes it work.
  • imtringued 30 minutes ago
    This is purely a fact of notation though. 0.999... is defined to be a "destination" and not an ongoing process such as "lim".

    So you cannot take 0.999... to the infinity-th power to get it to zero, you still get one. The issue is that you need to couple the exponent to the length of digits because the rate at which the exponent grows decides whether you go to zero or one.

  • bigfishrunning 9 minutes ago
    just to be pedantic, his base-2 proof is

      x=0.111…
      2⁢x=1.111…
      2⁢x–x=1
      x=1
    
    Proper notation in base 2 should be

      x=0.111…
      1⁢0x=1.111…
      10x–x=1
      x=1
    
    edit: getting the formatting right
  • noduerme 1 hour ago
    "Mixed base"?! I mean, it's a neat looking thing, 0.12345... but it's a tautology that if every digit represents the next base, and every digit increases, you're approaching 1.
    • dhosek 26 minutes ago
      But will you get there? After all 0.012345… also satisfies your statement but is clearly not 1.
      • noduerme 1 minute ago
        Hah! What a wonderful observation. I feel like this is a test; the previous statement seemed obvious to me, but now I'm past anything I can visualize. My gut feeling is that your train arrives at the same moment at an infinitely distant station as a function, even though algorithmically, it would always be trailing.
  • jareklupinski 1 hour ago
    a computer will believe anything as long as it's 1
  • XCSme 59 minutes ago
    > 7, in base 2, that's 31

    Huh? I didn't get that conversion part. How is he doing it?

    Like, how can you have a "3" in base 2?

    • dhosek 27 minutes ago
      31 in base 2 is 3*2+1=7. Digits retain their meanings from base 10, but place values change.

      Likewise AB in base 10 is A*10(=10*10)+B(=11)=111.

    • latexr 38 minutes ago
      [dead]
  • alienbaby 52 minutes ago
    I dont get it. Unless you say 0.999... is 1. And then, just write 1. If you really mean something very close to one but not one, say 0.9999...

    ?

    • bazoom42 34 minutes ago
      No, because 0.9999… is 1, as shown in the article.
    • dhosek 24 minutes ago
      No, that’s not the definition of the … in a repeating decimal. The definition is the limit of the sequence .9, .99, .999, … as the number of digits reaches infinity.