Mem Is Shutting Down

(get.mem.ai)

42 points | by qainsights 4 hours ago

14 comments

  • talmr 19 minutes ago
    I’ve been talking to (small/mid) business owners, consultants, etc.

    Many of them say they don’t care about integrations or AI.

  • maplet 2 hours ago
    Reminds me of kepano's File Over App [1] philosophy.

    > Apps are ephemeral, but your files have a chance to last.

    1: https://stephango.com/file-over-app

  • futuraperdita 4 hours ago
    Roughly $29 million in VC went to this product.
    • nylonstrung 18 minutes ago
      What an embarrassment given what Obsidian and Siyuan (which I like even better) have been able to achieve with such limited resources
    • VladVladikoff 3 hours ago
      What is the product? I’ve never heard of it before

      Edit: looked it up, it’s an AI note taking app from what I can tell.

      • freakynit 3 hours ago
        What da absoute fck!! $29 million for this? Seriously?
        • neya 1 hour ago
          We as engineers look at it and think about the effort needed to build something like that. Marketers look at the idea and think about numbers, what could be and slap some nice graphs on it, which is what VC firms like to see. They don't care if you can scale the backend to 100M users. To them, engineering is just another aspect that money can solve, so they throw more money at it later (such as hiring more engineers, getting a CTO who's also good at making powerpoint slides, etc)
        • guessmyname 2 hours ago
          Well, it has shutdown. You can vibe-slop an identical app/service to get another US$25M or more, depending on how ambitious and skilled you are at shit-talking… I mean, depends on how good you are at navigating VC meetings with persuasive talk. For better or worse, US$25M is not a lot compared to the extravagant sums of money thrown around Silicon Valley venture capital groups.
          • ChuckSneed 1 hour ago
            Wont work that easy now that AI bubble has popped. Though there would be a new bubble in yet another thing soon, so you can position yourself for that.
            • wk_end 13 minutes ago
              The AI bubble has popped?
          • userbinator 2 hours ago
            You can vibe-slop an identical app/service to get another US$25M or more

            Probably not, now that everyone realises they could do it themselves with AI.

    • xattt 3 hours ago
      Not familiar with the VC process. What happens with this? Is it written off, or do founders become metaphorical indentured servants?
      • Aurornis 3 hours ago
        > or do founders become metaphorical indentured servants?

        VCs invest in the company. They put money into the company and get equity in the company in return.

        It’s not a loan to the founders. So don’t worry, they’re not indentured servants and everyone, including the VCs, knew this was a possible outcome. In VC it’s actually the most likely outcome because most companies don’t become big successes or even become valuable stable businesses.

        What happens next: The remaining assets and liabilities will be settled up. Any remaining cash goes to the owners (equity), generally with some preference to paying back most recent investors first up (preference).

        If the founders performed well and the investors believed they were doing good work that didn’t pan out due to market conditions or bad luck, they may be interested in investing with those founders again later. Or they may be sour and not want to talk to them. I’ve seen more of the former than the latter. Most VCs try to avoid getting bad reputations so they’ll make an effort to stay on good terms with founders.

      • paimapi 3 hours ago
        VCs bet widely and hope they nab a big one that'll net billions in equity. Tossing a few million here or there to seed the field is part of the strategy (though you'd hope they're making smart bets and not just letting nepo babies through or getting swept up by an adept sales pitch but I've heard a lot of stories otherwise)
      • BetterThanSober 1 hour ago
        Given enough money and analysts of average competency acting in good faith, VC will almost always comes ahead

        See old YC stat https://www.ycombinator.com/blog/yc-stats/ one jackpot is enough to offsets the failure

      • weird-eye-issue 3 hours ago
        It's just simply a total loss, that's what happens the majority of times in these investments and they know that going into it
      • LastTrain 2 hours ago
        The data users shared with Mem gets sold to the highest bidder.
      • irjustin 1 hour ago
        Many of the responses aren't taking you seriously:

        - It is written off as an investment loss for that particular fund (commonly VCs have Fund 1, 2, 3).

        Then everyone moves on with their lives.

      • aizk 2 hours ago
        To VCs this is like a scratch off ticket.
    • kphorn 4 hours ago
      This is exactly the answer I came to this comment section for
    • alexpadula 3 hours ago
      Saw that on Linkedin. "We've raised $29M to date from the OpenAI Startup Fund, Andreessen Horowitz (a16z), Floodgate, Unusual Ventures, and other amazing investors."
    • cebert 2 hours ago
      I cannot believe that they were able to get $29 million in VC. There’s no moat here.
    • skybrian 2 hours ago
      Do you have a source?
  • skeledrew 4 hours ago
    Happy user of org-mode for the past 10 years. Nothing else is a flexible IMO.
    • keyle 2 hours ago
      Only 10? /s
  • ziofill 1 hour ago
    Ha, I didn't know about this. A few months ago I built an app to capture fleeting thoughts without breaking you flow: https://getquicklog.com/
  • privacyishuman 4 hours ago
    Is there any cross platform open source notes app with as good UI as Apple Notes?
    • orsenthil 4 hours ago
      Obsidian.
      • snowbeing 4 hours ago
        i would argue that obsidian has a better UI than apple notes, but it unfortunately isn't open source.
        • Grombobulous 2 hours ago
          I feel like the massive difficulty in self-hosting a sync server is intentional sabotage to make you pay for their cloud service.

          I can understand the economic reasons why but I don’t love it.

          • stavros 1 hour ago
            I've never tried to set it up, but how difficult can it be? Won't an LLM just set it up for you?
      • archargelod 2 hours ago
        beware: Obsidian runs on Electron - slow, sluggish, memory wasting piece of garbage.
        • egeozcan 2 hours ago
          That's why my gut tells me that somebody somewhere must have vibe-coded a 100% compatible rust based replacement.
    • glitchc 4 hours ago
      Yes, check out Standard Notes.
    • Onavo 3 hours ago
      Joplin, it's the only one that's end to end encrypted by default and reuses your existing cloud storage services instead of requiring a custom server. It also supports custom extensions and plugins.
      • vunderba 2 hours ago
        +1 for Joplin - but unless something's changed in the past few years, I can't stand the way they structure your notes.

        If you already have a well organized folder/subfolder of markdown notes, Joplin takes'em and shoves them into a SQLite table with UUID names, attached media is also renamed and stored under something like `~/.config/joplin-desktop/resources`.

        Makes it very difficult to use your existing notes with bash tools, etc. once Joplin has ingested them.

        • stavros 1 hour ago
          I'm fairly sure that an LLM can one-shot you a FUSE driver to expose the notes as a filesystem.
        • inopinatus 1 hour ago
          Fenced gardens are a -5 for any note taking utility. If the tool can't/won't use a filesystem to organize documents as files in folders, I assume the author was a moron. I don't mind if it has its own structured storage model as well for whatever reason, but skipping out on the most foundational persistence structure is an instant fail, being (amongst other sins) a mismatch for work trees. And import/export is friction, not an exemption.
  • pulkitsh1234 2 hours ago
    I have been building a note taking app which can launch Pi agents, running fully locally, backed by markdown: https://solipsist.sh/
    • throw03172019 2 hours ago
      This looks pretty cool actually. Great work
  • pelcg 4 hours ago
    Does anyone still use Mem? Haven't heard from them in a while until now.
    • skeledrew 4 hours ago
      That's why they're shutting down.
  • sreekanth850 2 hours ago
    This show how brainless and broken is investor ecosystem. How the hell they invest 29 million in a product with saturated market with 1 product launching every day?
  • orliesaurus 3 hours ago
    Surprised they lasted this long TBFH.
  • weikju 3 hours ago
    Queue Google/etc buying up all that data on the cheap for AI training...
  • cowpig 2 hours ago
    Odds your memories will be sold to Mercor?
  • ares623 3 hours ago
    And on the horizon, I saw a pale, white horse. And its rider was Death.
  • jocelyner 1 hour ago
    [dead]