How to CAD Almost Anything

(ocw.mit.edu)

256 points | by o4c 3 days ago

19 comments

  • mafm 7 hours ago
    There has been a recent explosion in open source cad options.

    fluidcad appears to be a remarkably good option now - particularly for something that only started development about a year ago.

    I have used freecad, solvespace and onshape for at least a hundred hours each to make some reasonably complex parts. fluidcad resolves pretty much everything I found painful about those options.

    I have some more limited experience with build123d which is also nice, but just not as easy and interactive as fluidcad.

    Fluidcad provides normal interactive 3d cad interface with tools like extrudes/revolves/sketches but explicitly generates code as an intermediate step to constructing geometry and the code can be edited and refactored easily.

    The linking between the code and the gui works remarkably well in practice.

    It’s far easier to manage parameters and constraints in fluidcad where they are written out explicitly and can be edited vs what happened in a gui-only interface like Onshape.

    If you’re playing around with a semi-constrained sketch to understand kinematics onshape tends to “helpfully” add random constraints which is really annoying to identify and correct. In fluidcad everything is way more explicit and visible and clear.

    I have only spent about 5 hours using fluidcad but it looks remarkably useful despite some minor rough edges. It’s pretty much exactly what I wanted onshape or build123d to be.

    Solvespace is a really beautiful piece of software but quite limited. fluidcad has the same sort of nice vibes as solvespace but is way more powerful.

    • eadz 3 hours ago
      I love open source ( although slightly less relevant now ), and so I spent many many hours using OpenSCAD to write parts that in hindsight would have taken me 1/10 time in something like Fusion. When I finally learned Fusion, I regretted not learning it earlier.

      However now everything has changed. I personally believe that the days of designing by hand are numbered. I think the current apps are a bit like the early days of AI assisted coding - autocompleting certain manual steps. Compared with full agentic "solve x" prompts.

      I've been working on my own AI-First CAD ( and CAM! ), thinking about everything from first principles for AI - is it easier to think in terms of operations? or start with the finished product? I'm pretty happy with the engine ( and kernel ) I've (+agents) built, it can do full assemblies, including interactive sliders to move them etc, and then do the 3 axis CAM ( or export to STL for printing). I'm really interested in genuine feedback if anyone has a few minutes to try it out www.zelm.ai.

      • adamweld 2 hours ago
        As a mechanical and software engineer I've been following this space closely, and similarly thinking about what interfaces will power the CAD packages of the future.

        I checked out your project but was a bit disappointed to see that it's closed source. As you're probably aware in the last 6 months there have been a ton of new OSS B-Rep kernels and CAD programs hitting the ground, many of them working towards the same goals that you and I have.

        It's my personal opinion is that in this new age of AI coding, the best way for a project like this to gain momentum and user base is to make it free and open for other users/contributors to work on and with.

        Just my 2c.

        • eadz 2 hours ago
          I totally get the sentiment, but I think software has changed quite a bit. If we're honest, AI 99.9% built this, I just provided the vision.

          I've contributed to open source, and ran my own open source projects in the past, but when everyone can have the software exactly they want it's just a different ballgame. I think the value of Zelm isn't so much the code, but the infrastructure around it to make it a seamless experience.

          If there is a feature you want, just ask for it in the chat or via MCP, and it will be added to the backlog automatically.

          Open source was never about free as in beer, but in this case Zelm is pretty close to free if you use it as a MCP server.

          • adamweld 1 hour ago
            I've been having some interesting discussions with friends about this exact topic, whether AI will be a boon to OSS, or the end of it.

            I think that many tools, services, and programs will be more personalized, and maybe less shared. But that the core building blocks of the tools will stay open and continue to be refined by the community.

            When I'm coding with AI, one of the main reasons it's so capable is the ability to build off of languages, packages, and frameworks that are battle tested across many deployments. The end result is better if my (+ my agents) focus is on what's new and different about what I want to create, not reinventing the wheel. So I'll import a proven serial library rather than writing my own, pick the right programming language for my use case rather than writing in assembly.

            With regards to your project and CAD, I think it's a clean and efficient interface, and part I generated looked good. Personally I need more traditional CAD features for my day to day (drawings, multi part assemblies, hand editing) but it looks like a good tool for the right use cases.

            To finish my open vs closed source thought - have you considered open sourcing your b-rep kernel? Your app may be the secret sauce, but the kernel is boring but vital core. Parasolid has been developed over the last 35 years and is the reference point. NVIDIA open sourced SMLib but it is buggy and incomplete. OCCT exists but doesn't handle fillets well. Zoo spent two years with tens of developers building their kernel from the ground up (also unfortunately closed). There are a dozen new kernels written in Rust on github but none are complete.

            I really think that if all of the smart people trying to roll their own kernel worked together and put effort into really completing a good open source kernel, it would be the start of a cambrian explosion of CAD tools and AI enabled hardware engineering tools. Food for thought.

            • eadz 1 hour ago
              Have you seen https://solidcraft.io/solidcore/ ? It's a rust CAD kernel and open source. It's a port from SMLib. It also seems to have an active open source community.

              I don't really know much about CAD kernels, and so I really don't think I should be running a cad kernel open source project/community ( which is what successful open source is about ) I wouldn't be able to decide if we should do feature x or not.

              > Personally I need more traditional CAD features for my day to day (drawings, multi part assemblies, hand editing)

              Zelm supports drawings ( including custom drawings, see Download button ), assemblies ( with movement interfaces, click on Features ), and while it doesn't support hand editing ( i.e. with a mouse ), designs are parametric so you can tweak them ( click on Params down the bottom ).

              This is an example: https://www.zelm.ai/p/v8nzvHBhz7?share=Kis1TuAUtwn7nR3VNx-rj...

              • imtringued 1 hour ago
                >I don't really know much about CAD kernels, and so I really don't think I should be running a cad kernel open source project/community ( which is what successful open source is about ) I wouldn't be able to decide if we should do feature x or not.

                Is this some kind of joke I'm not getting? People use AI to do things so far outside their competency to the point where they have no idea about anything? I mean, who exactly would trust such a project? I'd rather do it myself.

                • eadz 46 minutes ago
                  > People use AI to do things so far outside their competency

                  yes, if you want to do things far outside of your competency

                  > I mean, who exactly would trust such a project?

                  Depends how it can be verified. In this case there are potentially easy solutions, print it on a 3d printer and measure it. Is it 30mm across?

      • reillyrider 1 hour ago
        I'm not really sure about AI CAD. The things I CAD are very specific, I can't just go "give me a generic box", it needs to be these exact dimensions, it needs to have cutouts at this position with this size, it needs holes at this spot, manufactured with these materials and tolerances, then I need this all nicely parametric and easy to change. If I need to put that many specific details in my prompt (and then double check the work afterwards) I might as well just do it myself.

        And how would iteration look like? It's a million times faster and easier to just navigate around a 3d model, click on the feature to edit, start editing. Describing which feature for the AI to change seems like a nightmare.

    • maouida 29 minutes ago
      FluidCAD author here. Thank you for review.

      To be honest, I did not expect it to reach this level of interactivity when I first started it. I only wanted to add few interative features to make CAD by code more enjoyable. Now it has become more of UI driven CAD with the code there when you hit a wall.

      I'm going to add tools for surface modeling + tech drawings soon then I'll lock features for v1.

    • NegativeLatency 5 hours ago
      Been a free tier fusion 360 user for years and recently switched to solid craft, it’s been amazing. Faster and nicer for what I do (3d printing stuff mostly) no cloud stuff and I can also use it via MCP which I find to be a nicer workflow than openscad

      https://solidcraft.io/

      Freecad never really worked for me well would get stuck frequently and not be able to figure it out.

      • omnimus 1 hour ago
        This is probably best full on AI clone we've seen. It is very bad news for all the established (Adobe, Autodesk) software.

        The authors have this custom process where humans pick yes/no on features/commits without looking at the code at all. The are abusing many claude 200usd subs and the tokens costs are apparently close to 100k usd.

        But still this is very bad news for traditional software.

      • mft_ 47 minutes ago
        +1

        I’m now using Solidcraft as a daily driver and it’s great. Some areas seem perhaps a bit ‘fragile’ (filleting, possibly surfacing) but overall it’s very stable and usable.

    • YuechenLi 4 hours ago
      Well, if you like code CAD, I think I've finally got my implementation of CAD app to a state that isn't absolutely embarrassing now, if people would like to try it out.

      https://helios-cad-wasm.yuechenli.chatgpt.site/

      Be warned though, the Firmament DSL used is designed to be LLM friendly, so it's a language that's way easier to read than it is to write, and it has a very nontraditional constraint system.

      • eadz 3 hours ago
        This is quite cool, I think you had some similar ideas to mine. With LLMs your parts can at least be named nicely! What is nontraditional about your constraint system?
        • YuechenLi 2 hours ago
          There is no traditional 2D constraint solver for parallel/perpendicular/equal, etc. Instead, constraints are requirements generalized in code as Concepts and construction geometries (planes, axis, profiles, etc.) are unified as Concept Structs and erased at compile time like TypeScript, so over/under-constraint for sketches doesn't exist because the constraints are explicit and pre-resolved.

          It's easier if I show you some sample code.

          https://github.com/yuechen-li-dev/Aetheris/blob/master/fixtu...

    • WillAdams 6 hours ago
      FluidCAD looks very interesting, but when I tried it I got:

      >The FluidCAD engine did not start within 30s.

      which is an open issue: https://github.com/Fluid-CAD/FluidCAD/issues/80

      • mafm 6 hours ago
        Not sure what the issue is. I did see that a couple of times on a slow windows vm but it stopped happening after I reopened the app.

        I tried it again a few days later on a Mac and went through a couple of the tutorials and then did a couple of hours of actual work without any major issues.

        So yeah, definitely some rough edges at the moment, but once I got past those, the overall experience was surprisingly good.

      • braiamp 6 hours ago
        > which is an open issue

        > closed this as completedon Oct 5

        Hmmm?

    • kilpikaarna 27 minutes ago
      Sounds interesting, but, sigh, javascript…
    • SilentM68 6 hours ago
      >> There has been a recent explosion in open source cad options.

      Yea, especially more so with ArtCraft cloning the more expensive stuff.

      It would not surprise me to see ArtCraft versions of DS CATIA/MatLab/Wolfram that can compete with the originals, in the near future.

  • statenjason 9 hours ago
    MangoJelly’s FreeCAD courses on YouTube took me from zero to dangerous enough to design my own prints. I appreciated his approach of modeling a part and then modeling it again with an improved method.

    https://youtube.com/@MangoJellySolutions/

    • WillAdams 9 hours ago
      I've watched a fair number of these, but I always get hung up on some tiny little interface difference which confuses me.

      Even bought a book which was purportedly for 1.1 (according to a bar across a corner of the cover), but when I got it, the text referenced 1.0 and the screengrabs were also for the older version.

      I am hopeful that the UI will settle down sufficiently with the nascent 26.3 that learning materials will catch up.

  • seemaze 9 hours ago
    These are great! I've been using CAD for the better part of three decades, from AutoCAD R14 to 3DS Max, SketchUP, Rhino 3D, Solidworks, Vectorworks, and now OnShape.

    Parametric solid modeling (OnShape in particular) is by far the most enjoyable (for me) of the conceptual frameworks which transform ideas in to geometry, though it seems one of the most difficult to intuit for newcomers.

    I highly recommend anyone interested give it a shot, there's never been a better time with more resources available to take advantage of the incredible capabilities of these tools.

    • dividedbyzero 7 hours ago
      I wish there was a way to have at least a small number of projects private with OnShape's free plan. With everything public I can't use existing models I have the right to use, but not to re-publish, that's very limiting. Their cheapest paid plan is way more than I could justify for occasional non-commercial hobbyist modelling.

      There doesn't seem to be anything but Fusion 360 that's viable for hobbyists, and I believe that limits the number of projects to some crazy low number.

      There is FreeCAD, and I really do like the idea of open source CAD, but I don't understand how people get anything just the slightest bit complex done on it given how rudimentary and anal its constraint solver is. Dozens of hours of practice in it's still just painful in a way no other solver I've used has ever been, sucks all of the joy right out of the process. It's really not for me.

      I'm stuck with SolveSpace for the time being, which is much much nicer to use than FreeCAD, but extremely limited feature-wise, and it has a bunch of annoying bugs.

      I get why the big commercial players do it this way, but it sucks that there isn't some affordable non-commercial option for one of the established tools.

      • adamweld 2 hours ago
        Realistically, for non-commercial hobbyist work, your best option is to just use OnShape and leave your models public. With a random name, no one is likely to find your work.

        Fusion lets you have private models, 10 of which can be active at any time. I personally prefer OnShape as a software.

        You can try some of the recent OSS clones hitting the web, e.g. SolidCraft as a Fusion replacement or CadRs for onshape. But expect some rough edges as the geometric kernel implementations are still very young compared to Parasolid which is the kernel used by most of the big dogs.

      • WillAdams 6 hours ago
        If you want something in-between FreeCAD and SolveSpace there is Dune 3D:

        https://dune3d.org/

        which has been discussed here previously:

        https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37979758

        https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40228068

        https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47475417

      • wlesieutre 2 hours ago
        Alibre Atom3D is currently 40% off for November sale, puts the one-time purchase at $120 and you can buy a year of updates later for $50.

        Currently Windows only, but the last major release cut out a lot of old .NET stuff and porting to other platforms is more likely now.

      • NegativeLatency 5 hours ago
        Would recommend trying solidcraft
    • tootie 7 hours ago
      I've done some CAD training online (also onshape) and have gotten pretty handy and designed some things for my 3d printer. I can make whatever shapes but it all looks like crap and wilts quickly under load. I'd love any advice or resources for actually understanding functional and aesthetic principles. Or does it just come with experience?
      • jononor 56 minutes ago
        For FDM 3d printing print/layer orientation is key to understand, as well as the concept of stress concentration. NeedItMakeIt I think has some nice videos around making strong functional parts, afair.

        For astetics I recommend doing an exercise where you make N=3+ variations of a simple part, with only differences in look. By simple think something like a clothes hanger, even angle bracket for shelves, a cup, etc. Experiment with different shapes and details. Repeat regularly with new parts, and over time you will develop a sense for different styles are achieved, and also develop your own style (or styles).

      • darksim905 4 hours ago
        I guess I never looked at the definition of wilt in relation to an item, but interesting.

        Telling you things you probably already know, but, there's designing an object and the representation of that (CAD) and then the creation of that in a real space and printing it (3D printing). The slicer that does the translation of how to go about printing that, is doing a lot of your interpretation and will define your quality of the item you are printing.

        My understanding is, different slicers have different feature sets and work good/better/best with different printers. Inherently, the same CAD file printed by several different printers, with different infil and different configurations, beds, heat, filament will all have different feel and function in terms of quality.

        I'm drawing a blank on the channel , but I'm positive there are a few YouTube channels that cover infil and how it affects the quality of a finished 3D print. Some of these concepts are no different than design principles for buildings and such that actual engineers™ learn and utilize.

        Once you get comfortable with those concepts (e.g. using honeycomb infil in some parts that need to be more rigid vs solid for something you want to survive -- also note the infil percentages) that's when you can combine that with how something pieces together and how to survive in different operating conditions.

        To your question: experience is the hard, costly and pain in the butt way to do these things. Finding a YouTuber you like and watching their content and experiences of the outcome of something they designed and why they made the choices they did, is free and implementing those ideas should* be painless.

        I know this isn't as much of a thing anymore, but I guess the quality for printing overall with certain filaments so good quality people don't mess with acetone baths for products anymore (I think it depends on filament). That finish can also make things look a lot better quality as well.

        Another variable in all of this that changes things is bed adhesion. If you don't have a good starting ground, there's nothing for everything else to connect to.

      • NegativeLatency 5 hours ago
        Try looking at stuff you see and think about how you’d make it or how they made it

        I don’t really know how to make stuff beautiful but I don’t know if 3d printing has really been around long enough to develop its own signature styles. There are existing design styles you can copy though.

    • vermilingua 7 hours ago
      I’ve used FreeCAD and now mainly use Fusion360, but am absolutely fed up with Fusion’s performance and terrible cloud setup. Is OnShape comparable on its free plan?
      • NegativeLatency 5 hours ago
        Was in the same boat until last weekend, try https://solidcraft.io/
        • seemaze 5 hours ago
          will check it out!
          • NegativeLatency 3 hours ago
            I’m sure it’s got lots of bugs being so new but the community looks really promising and it’s worked great for my simple to mid complexity 3d printing needs
      • seemaze 5 hours ago
        There are two big caveats with OnShape when using the free tier:

        1. OnShape is browser based only. This has benefits and drawbacks.

        2. OnShape free tier models are all open, as in the equivalent of a public github repo.

        For me, the quality of the product is worth those trade-offs.

  • beering 10 hours ago
    Despite AI being able to do all this already, I still think it’s a very interesting skill to learn because almost all products around you are designed this way. For better or for worse, you will be able to see how CAD affected the design of products you touch or see.
    • manbash 7 hours ago
      Do you have an example? Last I checked, AI did bad meshes and didn't use common techniques. I believe it was back when stable diffusion was employed, though.
      • dagmx 6 hours ago
        CAD isn’t polygonal geometry be definition.

        Polygonal geometry is harder for GenAI to do because it’s still largely diffusion based to look like an object and topology is just a polygonal projection over it. It’s roughly equivalent to the diffusion model generating the image inputs to photogrammetry (not quite but a trivialized explanation)

        Meanwhile CAD is represented as a series of B-rep surfaces and operations. Both are largely more procedural and more akin to a programming language for models. Therefore it’s easier for an LLM to drive something towards an end result.

        Then the CAD engines tessellator generates the polygons, but topology is not super important for CAD.

        The best LLM CAD results I’ve seen even in academia are largely simplistic still though. The more data you put in , the better it’ll be able to match that but it’s sort of like giving it a very clear set of functions it can do to make something.

      • adamlrhodes 7 hours ago
        Over this past weekend I had Claude Opus 5.5 medium design some components using openscad, combined with some hobby servos and an arduino to make a robot arm, and then I printed them on my 3d printer and assembled them.

        Granted, it wasn't perfect, but it got pretty close, and with some light iterating, the finished result is not bad. Giving it access to prusaslicer as a tool helped it catch some common mistakes like overhang early too.

        https://github.com/AdamRhodes/robot-arm-public/tree/main/par...

        Checkout some of the stls in the repo if you are curious the kinds of stuff it can already do fairly well.

        I'd recommend trying it again, it has gotten significantly better since the last time I tried it about a year ago.

      • averynicepen 5 hours ago
        The most recent examples of the state of the art are from the initial release of GPT Astra and later Opus 5.5, maybe one or two months ago. Blender has already had an MCP since early this year, but it wasn't until these models came out that they are now capable of spatial reasoning and spatial consistency to be able to create something in 3D.

        The way it works is the same way all other agentic AI works - feedback loops, and an AI driving a computer. The AI creates a shape in Blender, then takes orthographic view screenshots so it can "see" what it did, double checks its work against what the goal is, fixes errors if there are any, and then repeats until done.

        It is worth noting that using Blender creates mesh representation 3D models, and does not create the boundary representation 3D models used in CAD programs. But I don't see anything stopping the industry from creating a similar MCP or other AI-native interface for b-rep CAD programs.

        You can find the latest examples on social media or Youtube if you search for keywords Astra, Opus 5.5, and Blender.

        This is a notably different approach than many of the existing "text to 3D" or "image to 3D" generators, which train their own machine learning algorithm to output models. Those have also been getting better, but the latest in this field was Astra driving Blender.

  • userbinator 4 hours ago
    Students in this workshop learned basic CAD skills and reverse-engineering of an object into a 3D model.

    I wonder if this skill is one that comes naturally for some people, but is difficult and/or nonintuitive for others; perhaps it's related to the ability to imagine and mentally manipulate 3D objects in one's own mind, and translate between that and a 2D view. In the last century, when AutoCAD was one of the most pirated warez along with Photoshop, I had no trouble using the former to model various things I happened to have around, with just a bit of exploratory play and some reading of the online help.

    • martin_a 5 minutes ago
      > I wonder if this skill is one that comes naturally for some people, but is difficult and/or nonintuitive for others

      I think so, yes. I've seen the same in students tasked with learning programming. For some the handling of loops, recursion and other concepts is easy, they have an image of how that works in their head, for others it's complicated and frustrating because they lack that image.

      I think it's the same for CAD and looking at objects and reverse engineering how things were constructed or put together.

  • vogtb 10 hours ago
    I learned CAD back in 2016 from a guy on YouTube with a thick german accent. Ever couple of years I've needed to do something w/ some sort of CAD, mostly FreeCAD recently. It's nice to know I've not forgotten everything, but it's also interesting to play with the variety of MCPs and agent tools for CAD out there. Dictating that I want something to have holes at such and such a size, and spread 20 degrees apart and so on is interesting, and feels like essentially the same thing, but with a very specific image of what I want in my minds eye.

    The parts of this course seem generally the same to what I learned (although without the thick german accent) and probably translate equally well to the agent/mcp UX for CAD.

  • brudgers 1 day ago
  • Snibz 1 hour ago
    As a CAD (BIM) developer, I think the learning curve caused by the complexity of CAD software will remain a pain point for users, regardless of open source or not. I could see open source CAD's gain significant popularity if they were easy to get into, and perhaps more importantly, easy to extend and modify. The CAD and BIM software business is in large part about creating solutions to niche industry needs.
  • nightbun 8 hours ago
    This is weird timing.

    Just yesterday I setup Claude and Claude duet so I can just snap photos of a caliper in multiple ways around an object and let opus auto generate the model. Slice it in orcaslicer. Send to printer on LAN.

    Anything else I should know as I don’t want to have to do anything more than this to print items I need around the house

    • hackshack 8 hours ago
      Photogrammetry is the way. Many open and closed implementations. Higher resolution than FaceID and LiDAR sensors on iPhone. Keep the light and object in the same place; move camera around. Much higher fidelity.
      • coderenegade 7 hours ago
        That gives you a mesh, but for some applications (not the OP's) you might still want a BRep model, which is where the AI is still useful.
    • BirdieNZ 8 hours ago
      I want to get a flatbed scanner to take orthographic photos of items that I want precise measurements for to eliminate the caliper process, maybe that?
      • nightbun 8 hours ago
        Apparently iPhone lidar isn’t precise enough or else that would be neat to scan quick and instant print. Maybe it’s close enough for certain things.
  • binsquare 6 hours ago
    For phyaucal engineering, Cad wasn't particularly the bottleneck ffrom my perspective as we were able to teach young kids to cad at a pretty competent level.

    The rigor behind a functional design needs to consider physics, manufacturability, and real engineering was what is considered good or great CAD

    • horsawlarway 6 hours ago
      CAD is still a decent bottleneck here. It's simple to use basic tools to create something, it's hard to create precise copies or very specific models without a lot of learning.

      And I agree on the need to understand engineering. Neat thing is that 3d printers have gotten incredibly cheap and capable, and they are wonderful immediate feedback on how CAD translates to real manufacturing.

      Is that the same as more traditional manufacturing techniques? No. Is it close enough a lot of the learnings carry over? Yes.

    • adamweld 2 hours ago
      Yes, exactly. Making shapes is picked up quickly; good hardware engineering is so much more.
  • vhiremath4 9 hours ago
    If you are using Solidworks, I highly recommend Vertanux's SW course on YouTube. It's free, has example problems, and helped me really grasp the broad basics from bottoms up to tops-down assembly, drawings, etc.

    https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLROUP1bV8REQmZgDTTJ0JCanX...

  • WillAdams 7 hours ago
    So this has versions for:

    - Solidworks

    - Creo

    - Fusion

    - Inventor

    - OnShape

    - NX

    Is there any possibility of it getting updated for opensource options? FreeCAD would seem to be a good fit --- I'd love to see Dune 3D get some traction as well, and I'm very hopeful for the next version of SolveSpace which will add parameterization.

    • jlarocco 4 hours ago
      It pains me to say it, but CAD is one area where the open source options are light years behind the commercial offerings.

      Every open source CAD system seems to focus on geometric modelling or scripting geometric modelling because those are fun to work on. Those are important but small parts of what commercial CAD systems offer.

      FreeCAD, last I checked, didn't even have PMI.

      • jstanley 31 minutes ago
        Some of us refuse to use proprietary software, so the universe of viable CAD software consists only of open source software.

        From that perspective, the commercial offerings are the ones that are light-years behind, due to not even trying to compete.

        I've been using FreeCAD for 9 years, it is amazing software and has changed my life. Don't fear FreeCAD.

        I've also tried out Solidcraft recently, it is impressive software but very slow and I keep running into bugs, so FreeCAD still wins for now.

        > FreeCAD, last I checked, didn't even have PMI.

        I can count on no hands the number of times I have wanted this. It's not part of my workflow at all. It's hardly a dealbreaker.

      • YuechenLi 4 hours ago
        I wouldn't call geometric modeling "fun" to work on, you get to 80% of the way there super quickly, and the remaining 20%(boolean robustness, fillet/chamfer) is a never ending swamp if done with conventional approach.

        I think my implementation is the only open-source kernel with actual AP242 PMI support though and has the ability to label STEP files and generate 2D drawings directly from PMI. But it's code CAD and still fairly janky, if you want to try it out in the browser:

        https://helios-cad-wasm.yuechenli.chatgpt.site/

        Repo:

        https://github.com/yuechen-li-dev/HeliosCAD

        • jlarocco 4 hours ago
          Maybe "exciting" would be a better word than "fun"?

          People get excited about a cool looking 3D model. They don't get excited about implementing different PMI standards, or reading the ISO and AWS standards for weld symbols, or making sure a model saved 5 versions and 20 years ago still loads and behaves identical to how it did back then, or making sure hide/show in views from imported third-party formats works correctly.

          I took a look, but I didn't have any luck loading any of the NIST test STEP files from https://www.nist.gov/ctl/smart-connected-systems-division/sm...

          • YuechenLi 3 hours ago
            That's odd, considering I run round-trip import/export tests on the NIST test step files every commit.

            It works for me on both Chrome and Firefox.

            https://i.imgur.com/lWU5uP6.png https://i.imgur.com/2pyZ49X.png

            Do you have the error message when you try to import CTC-01? And did you use Open File instead of Import STEP and it didn't work? because if you did, that's probably something I should fix in the UI.

            • jlarocco 2 hours ago
              Sure: https://photos.smugmug.com/photos/i-qptfbk9/1/KMRfC7G6Trxfcx...

              I went through "Open File". When I tried just now some of the files opened, but several still failed.

              • YuechenLi 58 minutes ago
                Should be hotfixed now, and the NIST AP242 parts should import/export at least. The kernel was importing with default tolerance of 0.001mm instead of the part's declared tolerance of 0.01mm. Thanks.

                And I think you understand now why I said build a geometry kernel is really a slog sometimes.

      • adamweld 2 hours ago
        Six months ago I would have agreed with you, but recently some FOSS CAD programs have landed that have a level of polish that's caused me to change my thinking here. They are, for better or worse, mostly clones of commercial software.

        You can check out solidcraft as one example. Easily good enough now for hobbyist 3d printing workflows, and a user can follow tutorials for Fusion to get started.

        As a professional it'll be a while before I give up Creo, but maybe not more than a year or two before the open source projects are ready for broad adoption.

  • Buttons840 6 hours ago
    I'm interested in 3D modelling, and I'm wondering if something like this would be adjacent enough to offer a new perspective but still be useful in art rather than just technical CAD?
  • xnx 10 hours ago
    Probably a useful intro tutorial for basic traditional CAD, but I don't see any mention of photo to 3D or AI assisted CAD. Workflows must be very different now.
    • matchstickman23 10 hours ago
      Not really all that different so far, even in companies where AI is extremely encouraged. From what I've seen, AI can help with tangential tasks to the actual design (exploded views, interference checks, probably basic drafting layout, etc) but it's still not that great at designing mechanisms or things that will be "used". By which I mean that AI doesn't have the same understandings as a human designer for how an item is intended to be used or operated.
      • radish_spirit 9 hours ago
        I can second this. I'm at an extremely AI-forward company, and though there are very aggressive internal efforts to figure out AI-first CAD workflows, it's the general consensus that the technology just isn't quite there yet.
        • YuechenLi 9 hours ago
          Just curious, what do you think is lacking in the current AI-first CAD workflow that makes it less than production ready?

          Full disclosure, I'm currently trying to build something to solve this and it would be nice to get some market feedback.

          • zonkerdonker 3 hours ago
            Ill take a shot at answering. Im also an ME at a very AI forward company.

            The hard part of mechanical design isn't really the CAD. Ask any long time professional mechanical design engineer, and I can almost guaruntee you that they will tell you that they can CAD up a design faster than they can think it. There are AI tools that can absolutely help with some of the more tedious tasks in the process (2D specification and tolerancing, part families and variants, texture tables etc). The difficult part of the job is synthesizing the massive number of variables and requirements and finding an optimal solution. Current models have been trained on all sorts of 3D, not just functional mechanical designs. AI doesnt know that a MIM steel part from vendor X can have a thinner wall thickness compared to a diecast steel part from vendor y, which would mean x grams of weight saving which cpuld be used to shore up a weak area on the other side of the part. It doesnt know that a sharp corner near an injection gate can cause porosity in some materials. It's not good at designing strong parts in general. It doesnt know that the ID team wants a specific surface on an user-facing surface which requires draft angle minimums relative to the mold parting direction. And, if you take the time to gather all that data and then type it all out for a model, you would spend twice as long writing everything down in plain language as it would take to just CAD it up yourself.

            It can take months to gather all of these requirements piece by piece from all teams across the org (rf design, thermal, structural and FEA, aerodynamics, environmental ratings, safety, etc etc), and as the design matures things change as well.

            For professionals with training in the tools, CAD as it is now is already the most optimal method of getting a design into the computer, and that was never really the hardest part of the process anyway.

            • YuechenLi 1 hour ago
              So... many of these are just DFM checks, right? Requirement checks like draft angle minimum and refusal of sharp angles near gates can be enforced programmatically during build time, and in terms of strength of material those can be checked via fast FEA. You are correct that modeling is never the hard part and everything else that happens after modeling is, and I do agree with you that the current AI CAD is insufficient on that front because they overfocus on the modeling portion.
        • nitroedge 4 hours ago
          kind of like when people shrugged off AI's ability to do image generation because it always created 6 fingers. Same story, very soon it will generate exactly what takes us hours or weeks to model now in minutes.
      • criemen 9 hours ago
        I'm very curious about this. I don't know anything about this space, but saw that OpenAI was advertising their mechanical engineering capabilities for the 6.2 release. How large of a part of the job is what AI can do at the moment? Do you feel a big jump in capabilities on each model release?
    • numpad0 9 hours ago
      that's because those things are not yet viable
  • analog8374 8 hours ago
    I really do prefer using a programming language for describing 3D models. Like openscad.

    Yes, the openscad language is weird. Considering switching to python.

    Do you relate?

    • somat 2 hours ago
      Cadquery https://cadquery.github.io might be worth trying.
    • GreyStache 5 hours ago
      I think you will be pleased by build123d. Especially the math mode feels pythonic to me.

      Also works well in combination of your favourite AI: "using python and build123d in math mode generate a banana". I don't oneshot it, just plan the object in advance and lead it there step by step.

    • WillAdams 7 hours ago
      If you like OpenSCAD, but want to use Python, then PythonSCAD, which just updated to version 1.2 is what you are looking for:

      https://pythonscad.org/

  • sneak 9 hours ago
    I have been building objects in Satisfactory lately and it’s the first interface I have found that seems really intuitive for making 3d shapes. Is there any modeling software that works this way (like an fps with build/delete gun) or must I just bite the bullet and adapt to blender or fusion or something? A long time ago I figured out sketchup but it turned into some sort of cloud garbage now and even back then I recall it being slightly clunky.
    • rspeele 8 hours ago
      Not exactly what you are looking for, but I recommend following the Solvespace tutorial. It's short and simple and SolveSpace is a small download with a non-overwhelming number of features. It is harder to get lost in SolveSpace than in FreeCAD which is an absolute maze of "workbenches" and glued together features.

      https://solvespace.com/bracket.pl

      It is worth getting comfy with parametric sketch-based CAD because it's so powerful. It feels a lot like programming, really, in that by taking a good approach to modeling a part you can reduce or eliminate the amount of repetitive labor and make-this-line-up-with-that housekeeping you have to do.

      And the fundamentals transfer over to FreeCAD, Fusion, Solidworks, etc. pretty easily in the same way that once you know Java you can learn Python, C#, etc.

  • SilentM68 6 hours ago
    I don't see DS CATIA on the site? :(
  • mrdootdoot 8 hours ago
    Hey Claude you got freecad and Isaac sim, shame the establishment. Build me a digital twin worthy of Mordor.
  • bitwize 7 hours ago
    The same answer to everything else: ask Claude to do it