Show HN: Tinnitus frequency finder and audio notch tool

(trynotched.com)

83 points | by brianrhea 2 days ago

20 comments

  • torben-friis 2 hours ago
    For those of you who suffer tinnitus, specially if recent, I can't recommend enough a psychological therapy approach.

    I recently got tinnitus (about a year ago) due to a badly treated ear infection. Most of my hobbies (reading, coding, studying) are done in quiet spaces, so the idea that I would never hear silence again was devastating.

    But as my doctor pointed out, a signal being there forever does not mean you hear it forever: You currently have clothes brushing against your skin and your ass being pressed against a chair, but it doesn't occupy mental space.

    This is consistent with research. We are currently very limited in means to solve the physical issue, but we are very far ahead in terms of improving the distress or perceived effect.

    Nowadays I lie in bed in silence, just as peaceful as before. And sometimes this fact surprises me, and upon doing a double take, it wasn't silence, the noise is there. But I do have to check to notice. It's weird, much like how you don't breathe manually until you notice and then you have to consciously breathe for a few seconds until you forget about it.

    • _spduchamp 8 minutes ago
      My "cure" was getting into making drone/noise music. My gateway was listening to Éliane Radigue's Trilogie De La Mort day and night for a month, which f'd me up and changed the way I listen. Then having broken all the rules of music making, it opened a door to stroll through and explore.

      On the rare moments I notice the tinnitus, I treat it like a little bird visiting. Hello little bird.

    • therealpygon 2 hours ago
      I would only share to just be careful you don’t stray into the “you can cure your depression by just thinking positive” territory. Seems like what helped you was accepting you have it; people who have suffered for years, long ago accepting it, won’t suddenly “lie in bed in silence” just by thinking positive.

      Sorry you’ve had to join our team.

      • torben-friis 1 hour ago
        I understand that one shouldn't speak lightly and provide "false hope" magnifying results. But my problem was the opposite: My mental model, and probably a common one, was that any approach based on therapy was just stress management: In plain words, I thought I would still hear the damn noise, I would just learn to be content with that feeling.

        I was wrong in thinking that way. My results don't really match that experience. I truly, literally, don't hear the noise, even if the physical cause remains, unless I concentrate on hearing it.

        It hadn't clicked for me that this was possible. But in hindsight it's now obvious that this is how the mind works: I take cold baths regularly, the first ones were miserable and now they're fine. But it's not that I've become a tough guy that can ignore the cold; my first person perspective is that it's easier to handle because I literally, truly, don't receive feelings of coldness as intensely. If any cold bath felt like the first I would have ditched the idea long ago; they don't, luckily.

        I'm not saying that my results are achievable for everyone. It's anecdotal, and I am lucky that my particular hearing loss is very high pitched, so it doesn't interfere with actual hearing. YMMV. But it's important to understand what the range of success looks like, so people don't dismiss the option outright.

    • sgarland 2 hours ago
      Thank you, I’ll ask my therapist about this. The lack of silence is definitely the worst part for me. Music isn’t tremendously harmed; I think my brain has somewhat adjusted for the frequency scoop in one ear.
      • tapland 58 minutes ago
        Absolutely do that. Whatever the root cause, it won't hurt to at the very least get some coping advice
    • ourcat 1 hour ago
      As I try to go to sleep, I can just notice as my breathing calms right down, it goes away and everything is silent.
    • crefiz 1 hour ago
      Care to share what methodology was used? To be able to easily pass along the recommendation to the professional
      • torben-friis 42 minutes ago
        The words to look for are cognitive behavioral therapy (oriented for tinnitus), the specific exercises and techniques will vary by professional, I suppose.

        Part of what I trained for example is attention shifting, stuff like hearing two conversations at the same time and training the ability to move focus from one to the other, then shifting between sound and a different stimulus, like reading while a sound is on and switching attention from the text to the speech.

        Then you focus on acknowledging the existence of your tinnitus without checking it, which was hard for me to split apart. Basically, calming the demand of your brain to pay attention to the screech without in doing so shifting focus to the sound itself.

        An analogy that works for me is: Say that you're on your phone and you get an instagram notification. You don't want to open the app (focus on the sound) because it will distract you, BUT you don't want to pretend the notification isn't there either, because then the presence of the icon bothers you every few seconds. What you want is to acknowledge and dismiss without opening the app. Eventually you can dismiss with muscle memory without consciously registering it happened.

        I'm telling you this anecdotally, but I absolutely do not recommend self learning, a professional helps immensely.

    • ramoz 1 hour ago
      Sounds right. I've had it for years now due to medical treatment and only notice it when I read about it on HN.
    • paulnpace 48 minutes ago
      In my experience, this depends on the perceived volume level. The level was low for decades and I rarely noticed, but then the level increased and when I wake up at night, falling back to sleep is much harder than before, often just impossible.
    • TylerE 30 minutes ago
      > : You currently have clothes brushing against your skin and your ass being pressed against a chair, but it doesn't occupy mental space.

      For neurotypical people, maybe. For us autistics? We sure as shit are actively noticing that stuff.

  • huhtenberg 1 hour ago
    Alright, who else here has high-pitched low-volume version?

    I'd say in 11-13 KHz range. Not terribly loud, easy to tune out, but becomes apparent in quiet places and also becomes significantly louder when tired. Not unlike the sound CRT tubes (used to) make.

    To the OP - good stuff, thank you. After the part with 1-or-2 questions, the slider defaulted to the frequency that was much lower than needed. Had to crank it up quite a bit to arrive in the vicinity of what I'm actually hearing.

    ---

    Edit: for what it's worth, I ended up buying an in-ear camera to exclude dirt or debris touching the membrane as a cause. Had two ENT (ear-nose-throat) doctors peek inside as well, also nada. But I still think it's more of a mechanical issue of some sort rather than a psychological one as often suggested.

    • alex_duf 1 hour ago
      For me the frequency slider couldn't go high enough to match it.

      Same as you when I'm tired or got any sort of inflammatory response. I found through chatting to an LLM that because I hear it more loudly when I clench my jaw that it could get better if got my teeth fixed, so I'm getting my teeth fixed.

      It may not work but I've always wanted to fix my teeth, 42 ain't to old for that apparently.

      • huhtenberg 1 hour ago
        > when I clench my jaw

        Just tried it - it makes it louder and seems to lower the pitch a bit.

      • paulnpace 44 minutes ago
        > For me the frequency slider couldn't go high enough to match it.

        Is it possible this is a transducer frequency response issue?

    • brianrhea 39 minutes ago
      Thanks for trying it out! I will continue to fine-tune it. Hope you're able to find comfort.
    • alfiedotwtf 1 hour ago
      Are you sure that’s tinnitus rather than hearing blood pumping around your ear?

      When I take ADHD meds, I hear is pumping more than normal, so it’s definitely not tinnitus for me

      • huhtenberg 56 minutes ago
        I doubt it's that. There's no variation to it, just even buzz. It's also very high-pitched. What can it be there to produce 12KHz?
  • brianrhea 2 days ago
    I've had tinnitus for about a year and a half. There's no cure, so I'm trying anything that looks promising. One idea people are researching is listening to sound with a notch cut out right at your tinnitus frequency.

    The frequency finder will help you zero in on your tinnitus pitch. The method write-up is here: https://trynotched.com/how-pitch-matching-works

    Once you have a pitch, there's a free web app that plays background sounds (stream, rain, wind and so on) with a notch at your frequency: https://trynotched.com/tools.

    I built it as a PWA so you can save to your phone's home screen and it works offline. No account or time limit.

    • binsquare 2 days ago
      So I've had diagnosed tinnitus for the past 2 decades.

      I've tried what must be hundreds of these in the past but it never seems to apply to me. Is there a subset of tinnitus that this just doesn't work for? (Genuinely curious)

      • brianrhea 1 day ago
        Yo, I am completely sensitive to the reality that when it comes to effing tinnitus, somethings work for some people and don't for others. The notching research itself is mixed. My approach is to try anything that shows promise and this tool is letting me easily get in 4-6 hours a day of notched background noise.

        Truly, best of luck to you, and to all of us with tinnitus as we hold hope for a definitive cure.

      • s20n 3 hours ago
        This hn discussion might help you https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49234271
        • ricardobayes 51 minutes ago
          This excercise genuinely helped me, I don't notice it at all through the day and like the person commenting on the thread says, I only start noticing it again if I don't do the excercise for a while.
        • eurekin 3 hours ago
          Ah yes, I also suspect it's related to the forward heard posture and overactive muscles in the region (they attach very near to the ear).

          Especially this one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sternocleidomastoid_muscle

  • le-mark 2 hours ago
    PSA for any veterans who were in a recognized high noise MOS (artillery, armor, mortars, etc); there are proposed laws and VA proposed changes that will change how the VA compensates tinnitus, making it harder to get the minimum 10% rating. The application process is fairly streamlined nowadays through Va.gov. It took me about a month from applying to receiving a rating. Ai knows a lot about this and can guide you through the process. Tinnitus can cause secondary conditions like anxiety, insomnia and migraines which you can also get rating for.

    I put off applying for years due to the Va having such a bad reputation for denying everything. We’re in an era where they’re actually doing what they’re supposed to do (by their own regulations).

  • itomato 3 hours ago
    I made one of those in v0 out of frustration with the audiologist experience. https://v0-tinnitus-frequency-tool.vercel.app/

    Like other commenters, my response was well outside their measurement range. I had extreme highs and lows together. So many tests focus on a single tone, OP's included.

    Everybody is vibe-coding an app to suit their needs. We don't need more in the marketplace, we need to coordinate on the best paths for therapy.

    • TheCapn 1 hour ago
      The OPs link was mostly me going "nope, nope, nope... okay I guess this is closer." Then it just ended with a recommendation that was not close at all.

      This one comes closest to what I hear. I'm up at the 11,000Hz range with a mix of tones with some sort of out of band harmonic going on.

      With your link, I punched it up to 11,000Hz and immediately felt it was close. Once I toggled in the out of band and harmonic options it became almost nausious as it does match what I typically hear, but only louder which felt a bit like a gut punch in an odd way. Adding a second tone a bit lower got it closer. I hate it in a way but its wildly informative to know that what I hear apparently isn't typical?

      ---

      Remember folks. Wear fucking ear protection at concerts.

      • itomato 1 hour ago
        You can export the JSON and check your progress/healing
  • kmgallahan 55 minutes ago
    If you'd like to briefly experience silence I'd recommend the audionotch tuner here: https://audionotch.com/app/tune/

    Using Pure tone, hit Play, grab the thumb slider and roughly find your tone. Now hold the slider and slowly sweep above then below your tone by 1000-2000kHz. My tone is about 13kHz, so if I sweep from 11-15 for 30 seconds or longer, then I get temporary silence. Kind of a tease really, but it does seem to make your hearing system mute the ringing for a bit.

  • thih9 1 hour ago
    Don't listen to that in headphones in its current form.

    Step 7th lets you match the pitch yourself and it starts from different pitch - I don't know if it's randomly generated or not, but it blasted very high pitch unexpectedly and it was very unpleasant.

    This happened even when I took care to adjust the volume to a comfortable level.

    • brianrhea 37 minutes ago
      Oh no ... I will give that a very close and serious look. I'm sorry that happened!
  • anttiharju 54 minutes ago
    If you've tinnitus it's worth checking with your doctor if you could try Betaserc. It works for some, take 8mg 3x a day for some weeks, and maybe repeat every 4 years or so.
  • someone_old 3 hours ago
    I don't know if this is the same or not but every time I'm at home I hear a light buzz that I think comes from my neighbours. Seems that I'm the only one that hears it and feels super annoying, to the limit I just can't sleep at night. I use soft tones or things like whale sounds to sleep, but I'm wondering if there could be a way to find the "opposite" buzz to this one to make it silent in the same way the sound cancelling headphones do. Is this nuts, I'm going crazy or might this be something that can be done?
    • rustyhancock 3 hours ago
      The problem with an opposite buzz is you need to produce it at the right phase for it to reach your ears in antiphase with the problem buzz.

      The solution is usually acoustic masking where you produce noise which the buzzing melds with and your brain begins to ignore it.

      I suppose if it's a very loud buzzing you might add a notch to the white/pink noise to match levels.

    • jareklupinski 3 hours ago
      > find the "opposite" buzz to this one to make it silent

      destructive interference is how noise canceling works

      i experimented with silencing sirens by placing those "bass shakers" on a window, and using a DSP chip to listen to a mic outside and shake the window to "cancel" out the noise

      worked ok but i saw why you probably need a PhD to do the math right. or maybe an AI...

    • whoanoway 3 hours ago
      [dead]
  • Zebfross 3 hours ago
    PSA: I went to the doctor for tinnitus, and it ended up just being some earwax that fell against my eardrum. Got it fixed in a few minutes.
  • npongratz 53 minutes ago
    Nice that it claims to find a range, I hope it helps a lot of people. I can't imagine this approach helping people whose tinnitus exhibits multiple frequencies, each with different and changing volumes, per ear. (There are dozens of us, dozens!)
  • yakkomajuri 1 hour ago
    Genuine question: what's the usefulness of knowing the frequency?
  • sgarland 2 hours ago
    As someone who recently had unilateral sudden sensorineural hearing loss, thank you. I have a constant tone that I estimate to be around 6000 Hz in my right ear; I’ll be checking with this over the next few days to confirm.

    While I’m hopeful that it recovers (I caught it within a week and began a course of steroids, followed by middle-ear injections), I’m mentally preparing for that to not happen.

  • Lucasoato 3 hours ago
    I feel like my tinnitus ring is higher than what this tool is proposing, probably around 16k~17k, is this a good or a bad thing?
  • anilakar 2 hours ago
    It did not let me go high enough in the final check, 12k is too low.
  • minimaxa 3 hours ago
    My frequency is much higher; these seem more whooshing sounds. mine is definitely more like this at 5000hz?

    https://www.szynalski.com/tone-generator/

    • drittich 2 hours ago
      Same, this app seems to have a component of white noise. Mine is several very clear, high-pitched tones. Dominant one is near 7120 Hz.
  • hypfer 1 hour ago
    > Free for an hour a day. $12 once for no limit.

    Come on, this is just predatory. Baiting people with a cure to then paywall it. The whole idea of "Hey you suffer from a medical condition. I can help with that.. for money" when it's something so trivial, claude can recreate it in probably 20 minutes is.. unethical is not strong enough of a word.

    Actually, claude already built this, didn't it?

    Why not build something that doesn't live off human suffering? Why not monetize greatness. Why not make something that stands on its own instead of needing such genuinely evil tactics.

    If you want to hustle, pick something that isn't connected directly to daily pain of people. Do what the industry does and pick the indirect stuff.

    • hasbot 1 hour ago
      IMHO, it's a little silly to charge money for an AI assisted tool because if one person can do it then another three can too and eventually someone will just release it free open-source like this: https://github.com/Mathew-Harvey/WebFPVSimulator (not me btw).
    • cowlevel 1 hour ago
      I'm surprised Claude can just vibe up something that accepts real money over the internet. I always assumed there were huge barriers to doing that.
  • trimethylpurine 1 hour ago
    Missing from the FAQ:

    Why do I need this?

    What can I do with the results?

  • arpanghoshal 1 hour ago
    [dead]