What Happened to Silicon Valley?

(oreilly.com)

340 points | by greenyouse 4 hours ago

50 comments

  • Animats 3 hours ago
    Attempts at governance are futile until we recognize that we have built a machine and set it on its course. Instead, we pretend that the market is a natural phenomenon best left alone, and we fail to hold its mechanism designers to account. We need to tear down and rebuild that machine, reprogramming it so that human flourishing, not corporate profit, becomes its goal.

    This article has useful insights. It points out that capitalism is an optimization engine for something. Shareholder value and CEO compensation, mostly. It reminds us of something that many people would prefer be forgotten - capitalism operates under rules set by governments, and those shape the market. Tax law matters - what's deductible warps spending patterns. Bankruptcy law matters - who gets left holding the bag? Corporation law matters - how immune are executives from the consequences of their decisions? Labor law matters - do people go to jail for wage and hour law violations?

    All of those are changeable by legislation. Most have become much more favorable to companies since 1970. That's not necessarily permanent. We had a New Deal in the 1930s, following the Gilded Age of the 1920s and the crash of 1929.

    • WalterBright 1 minute ago
      > reprogramming it so that human flourishing, not corporate profit, becomes its goal.

      Profits enable people to flourish.

    • ianburrell 20 minutes ago
      BTW, the Gilded Age wasn't the 1920s. It was the period from late 1870s to late 1890s. It ended in Progressive Era where there were lots of reforms. That ended after WW1, then the boom of Roaring Twenties, followed by bust of 1929 and New Deal in 1933.
    • erentz 2 hours ago
      + Consumer law and competition law matters. We never had good regulation around this in the US, but what we did have we stopped enforcing. Tech companies were simply able to buy their potential competition whenever it arose for the past 20 years.
      • torben-friis 4 minutes ago
        >Tech companies were simply able to buy their potential competition whenever it arose for the past 20 years.

        Or outcompete them with unsustainable value propositions. Offering a service near free and taking the loss until competitors go broke, then enshittifyng the monopolized market.

      • mixmastamyk 1 hour ago
        +antitrust
    • Melatonic 3 minutes ago
      We also got labor unions out of that age
    • avarun 14 minutes ago
      Where do you get the notion that capitalism is an optimization engine? The purpose of "capitalism" (a vaguely defined phrase, but I'll assume you're using it to refer to a set of governmental policies that enable private ownership of enterprise and the capture of profit by said owners) is primarily to align incentives in society. It functions with the belief that humans are inherently driven by selfish goals and desires. Left alone in a vacuum, humans orient themselves towards activities which increase their own resources, standing, influence, and power.

      The purpose of capitalism is simply to take that natural orientation and align it with society's broader goals. This maximizes the odds that those who succeed at increasing their own resources will, as a natural byproduct, create resources for others as well. This has been a massive success so far (see https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/world-population-in-extre...) on a level not seen under previous political and economy philosophies.

    • Buttons840 1 hour ago
      Labor income is taxed more than capital gains, and, as far as I know, this is simply a choice we've made and isn't based on economic theory or anything deeper.

      I'm pretty nihilistic when it comes to the stock market and such. For instance, why was Anthropic's recent IPO valuable for the company? Why did people buy the stocks? The most common answer is that stocks provide ownership, but if somebody bought ALL the shares that were offered in the IPO, they would not have ownership of the company. So, why are the stocks valuable?

      I asked this in another HN thread and the answer was that the stocks are valuable because they increase in value. The price goes up because the price goes up. What more is there to understand?

      Why is the value of Anthropic stock connected at all to the performance of Anthropic the company? Is it all just social conditioning? Is it like gold, only valuable because we have been conditioned to think it's valuable?

      And, look, it's fine if it's just social conditioning. The economy is a social construct after all...

      The real difficulties start to come when you ask why stocks make some people who don't work rich while other people who do work are poor. I would hope for a little more than "social conditioning" to underlie that fact.

      • proc0 40 minutes ago
        The value comes from predicting the future. If you can predict where the value is and you get there first, you benefit first. The engine of markets is predicting value, which itself has value.

        It's really a "game" in the abstract sense, it has rules, it has objectives and rewards. The big problem in society is that a huge portion of the population aren't aware it is like a "game" that you need "play" and also get good at. The other problem is that we have no alternative to producing so much wealth and quality of life. This "game" could easily be inevitable because in fact there are no infinite resources so at some point sooner or later competition arises.

        The "game" could be violent (i.e. wars) or it could be peaceful where losers understand they lost and now have to adjust and compete in the market differently.

      • robberth 46 minutes ago
        Holding stock brings two fundamental benefits: control over the company and a claim on dividends. There is interest for both things, and from there on I guess it is indeed just supply and demand. But that demand is not only based on social construct or the belief that "stock will go up".
        • Buttons840 26 minutes ago
          The dividends make sense to me. This make stocks sound like a variable rate bond, where it pays out periodically--it's like a legal money printer, of course that would be valuable.

          But I get the feeling if I dig into it that most stocks do not actually pay much in dividends. If I do the math are the dividends alone going to justify the price of stocks? I doubt it. I'm happy to here otherwise, if anyone wants to make the claim that dividend payouts justify the value of stocks.

          As for the other reason, ownership, as I said in my OP, name one instance where ownership was actually obtained through stock purchases. There's a handwavey trick here were people say "well, any stock grants ownership, you are a part owner because you own 1 share!" but what does that mean in practice? If I own 1 share of Walmart, what is the most ownership-like thing I am able to do? Can I walk into the back--walk around like I own the place?

          The theoretical reasons for stock value never seem to actually manifest themselves in reality. What does manifest in reality is investors becoming more wealthy than those who labor.

        • benregenspan 42 minutes ago
          Anthropic's stock structure is inspired by Meta's, so most shareholders do not get any control over the company.
          • avarun 12 minutes ago
            The comment you are replying to is pointing out that "ownership" manifests as both a claim over future profits as well as voting rights. Thus, even if the latter is worth nothing (as in this case) ownership still has inherent value, contrary to the claim that it is pure speculation.
      • cowlevel 1 hour ago
        It's literally as simple as the ones with lots of capital set the tax rates, directly or indirectly.

        Capitalism is not fundamental, it has layers below it. At the bottom of the stack is game theory, the most horrific force in the universe.

        For SCP fans, SCP-3125 is probably (in-universe) a full intuitive understanding of game theory.

      • lazide 1 hour ago
        Eh, there is a fundamental difference in how they perform, especially if the tax is a ‘wealth tax’.

        Capital asset value is not liquid like wages are.

        Capital gains also only generally apply when transfer of control occurs, which is fundamentally different than regular wages.

        From a policy perspective, it’s the difference between a dairy farm and a timber farm.

        Any common rule applied to both will definitely be wrong for one of them.

        • Buttons840 44 minutes ago
          Eventually both things generate money that is transferred to a person for their own personal use and enjoyment. They might buy food, or a house, or 10 houses and a yacht, whatever the choose.

          At some point the money is transferred to a person to spend for themselves, it is then taxed. If that money was earned through labor it is taxed at a higher rate. If that money was earned through investments, it is taxed at a lesser rate.

          It looks like a pretty apples to apples comparison to me. It's just that we have chosen to economically reward investments more than labor.

          • lazide 26 minutes ago
            Your ignorance is showing. Capital might never do any of those things, ever. Or if so, not during the lifetime of the owner. Or might do then without any money changing hands.

            When it does so regularly, it’s called income and taxed accordingly.

            Most capital goods that people deal with are valuable because of money they end up not spending, rather than income earned directly.

            Fundamentally different than income.

            • Buttons840 12 minutes ago
              Sure, I'll admit ignorance. That's why I'm asking questions.

              It sounds like you mostly agree with my earlier assertion that labor is taxed at a higher rate.

              You admit that a great store of value exists in "capital goods" that are traded, and that benefit individuals, and you admit that those are often never taxed.

              Is labor ever NOT taxed? Labor is always taxed I think.

              Thus, I claim that labor is taxed more than investments.

              I guess we're about to go in circles though. You'll say that they are taxed different because they are different.

              I'm looking for a good reason to explain why labor is taxed more than investments. "They're different" is not a good reason--it's not really a reason at all, though it may be an accurate observation.

    • leoc 1 hour ago
      But not only is it changeable, it was already changed in the case of Alphabet/Google, by its dual-class share structure. Whatever is happening there and elsewhere, it's not simply a logic-of-capitalism story about a requirement to make the line keep going up. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50604114

      It's also just not true that these are problems that are likely to be fully, or even adequately, addressed purely at Layer 8 through political strictures. Many of them have partial root causes deep in the technical inadequacies of the existing HTTP(S) Web, a system which was a fine interim solution in the year 2000 or so but a disaster to still have in place a quarter-century later. The single thing that is most urgently needed is a truly adequate content-addressed replacement for (or layer above) HTTP(S), and progress on that is looking halting at best. The "hackers" can't really put the primary blame on the CEOs or politicians for that one.

      • tosapple 1 hour ago
        it's a disaster in place due to complicity and abrogation.

        i got told the other day on this very site i was advocating for a communist revolution, maybe I'll get downvoted some more.

        it doesn't take a revolution (unregulated Laissez-faire is an extremists ideology, only the military should have absolute access to foreign markets), it takes spending on unbiased(if possible) economists instead of political strategists and direct investment in jobs (500m in texas elections?) instead of advertising.

        and yeah, we can blame politicians, for labelling things like tor i2p freenet and vpns suspected terrorist activity when they are reactions to blatant violations and looking the other way about the very concept of a Union formed around a constitution and bill of rights.

        we are to be secure in our papers and THEIR effects.

        effects of their papers could be interpreted as unlocking a grapheneos phone with a piece of paper.

        "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects,[a] against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."

        SV is no different than the British.

        we enshrined misdirection and anonimity at the Boston tea party.

        that incident involved taxes and performance enhancing drugs e.g. caffeine and sugar.

        what we need is a group of constitutionalists who recognize that it's the 21st century, we have a right to bear arms and free speech.

        encryption is an arm, it has been judged as such. it overlaps with speech and freedom of the press.

        small radios probably routers, phones, and small flir enabled drones are also right[edit, subst] to bear arms.

        if those rights are not protected, we don't have a meeting of the minds or a valid Union. just a taxation scheme that is unresponsive like during the colonial era.

        downvote me, this is redress.

        2nd edit: addendum for something else i said the other day: if i buy a chair or table, and need to reinforce it with screws after some use, I CAN DO THAT.

    • ipdashc 1 hour ago
      > All of those are changeable by legislation.

      At times it feels like we've completely given up on this in the US. Even among the paltry "left wing" we've got, it seems like all that ever gets called for is stuff like "put CEOs in jail" or "end billionaires" which is ultimately useless and unactionable. Nobody prominent ever suggests an actual law that should be passed, a policy that should be changed, even a corporate behavior that they want to change.

      It certainly doesn't help that the Congress appears to be useless, but this learned helplessness isn't getting us anywhere.

      • BrenBarn 51 minutes ago
        I don't think that's true. People have, for instance, proposed things like eliminating the favorable tax treatment of capital gains, instituting wealth taxes, dramatically raising income tax rates on high earners, raising estate taxes, eliminating caps on Social Security taxes, etc.

        That said, we shouldn't discount the possibility of putting CEOs in jail, or of "ending billionaires" by the immediate confiscation of large amounts of wealth.

      • ToucanLoucan 1 hour ago
        As a leftist: there is no left of center party in America. The democrats are at best, centrist and frankly on any reasonable political scale they’re right leaning too. They just look better because the right here are out of their fucking minds entirely.

        I hope with all the new blood getting into the democrats this past midterm this can start to change, but status quo here for half a century has been no meaningful regulation at all on private businesses, and it shows in the utter shit quality of most of them.

    • mxfactorial 1 hour ago
      > capitalism is an optimization engine for something

      returns signal where capital can fund more r&d that produces more returns: https://github.com/systemaccounting/gradienterp

    • xqcgrek2 2 hours ago
      The Gilded Age is defined at the 1880s, and the railway/steel boom, after the 1870s depression.

      The 1920s boom was mostly due to electrification.

      • marginalia_nu 1 hour ago
        A lot of the hangover from the gilded age carried into the 1900s though. E.g. Standard Oil wasn't broken up until 1911.
      • pfdietz 1 hour ago
        I've been amused by the then-existence of the American Superpower Corporation (an electric utility holding company).
    • KaiserPro 2 hours ago
      I was thinking about the industrialists of the late 1800s early 1900s.

      Had we explained to them what modern capitalism is doing, they would be probably quite impressed by the productivity gains, but utterly perplexed at the offshoring and outsourcing to other countries.

      Yes, it makes things cheaper, but they also knew about manufacturing bases required for defence, and innovation.

      • randysalami 1 hour ago
        This kind of capitalism isn't about making America strong. That idea is dead.
      • bayarearefugee 2 hours ago
        > but they also knew about manufacturing bases required for defence, and innovation.

        And more broadly they understood that completely impoverishing your customer base leads to eventual ruin.

        Henry Ford was a piece of shit and plenty exploitative, but he at least understood that it benefited him in the long run to keep the cycle of production and consumption running.

        Now we're in underpants gnomes territory.

        Phase 1. Put everyone out of work as fast as we can

        Phase 2. ?

        Phase 3. Profit!

        • kodebach 30 minutes ago
          Yup, every time this topic comes up, I have to think about Dodge v. Ford Motor Co. The court case that enshrined shareholder primacy and put the US on the path to its current form of capitalism. And every time I'm amazed at the thought that Henry Ford, despite being a giant asshole, was on the correct side here. He was sued, because he wanted to spread his wealth and share it with workers instead of paying dividends to shareholders. Clearly he understood where his wealth came from.
    • hn_throwaway_99 2 hours ago
      There is a popular health blogger, Dr. Jessica Knurick, who makes similar arguments regarding the generally very poor health outcomes in the US, and I think her arguments are very persuasive. That is, our poor health outcomes are the logical consequence (not some anomaly) of a system that is designed to prioritize corporate profits over all other considerations.

      The thing I find most convincing about these arguments is that I often hear many "free market boosters" say that any intervention in markets is a foolhardy idea, and that individuals are best equipped to make their own decisions. But IMO this is a BS argument because it pretends that we don't already have tons of rules built into the system that prioritize specific values and outcomes (e.g. how corporate formation often protects individuals from some disastrous consequences of their decisions).

      I think that's the most important idea in these discussions: we do not live in some "default" state of fair, open competition. The system we built is a consequence of the rules we laid down to bring it into creation, and we can change those rules if we decide the current outcome is not what we desire.

      • anubistheta 1 hour ago
        But interestingly, when you look at the actual outcomes of procedures, the US healthcare systems is as good or better than others. The systems isn't even designed to prioritize corporate profits. It may be frustrating, but it's true. Respecting people's basic rights does tend to lead to better outcomes. Trying to tilt the system in your favor isn't the right outcome either. Do you really want people who hold the opposite values from you deciding the same thing?
        • antiframe 1 hour ago
          If you look at outcome of procedures you are measuring the wrong thing. If 100k people need a specific procedure and only 1k can afford it but they all have good outcomes your metric is 100% good outcomes. But if you have a system where 90k can get the procedure but only 90% have good outcomes you measure a worse system where 7900% more people got the care they needed.
      • bombcar 1 hour ago
        the big problem is that once you realize "individuals are best equipped to make their own decisions" is a big pile of hooey the entire modern world collapses.

        You end up having to hold that people aren't equipped to control what they put in their bodies, but they are equipped to control what they put in the government.

        • hashstring 1 hour ago
          I think there is nuance in what you are equipped to decide over.

          Humans should be protected from eating or drinking toxic food. It’s important that we do not have to second guess everything / be tricked into doing bad things by our brain’s “fast thinking” reward-centre wiring.

          However, with choosing leadership and governments, the decision is one you can (and should get supported in) invest time in, and then choose. It’s better to make that decision after meditating on it for a while, rather than having to make a million of micro-decisions daily that can have terrible consequences if you select the wrong one.

          I think I’m not entirely clear in my writings here, probably, but the gist is: there are differences in choices and it’s not as black and white as you put it, I believe.

        • 1718627440 1 hour ago
          That is only a problem for some specific understandings of e.g. democracy. I once read (C.S. Lewis), that while most people believe in democracy, because all people are capable of governing, he believes in democracy, because no-one is actually capable of governing.

          You also have major world religions already who operate under the assumption, that no human is capable of acting consistently moral, and the claim that you do is itself immoral. (=Christianity)

          This is not the novel problem, that you make it sound.

        • cowlevel 1 hour ago
          Not necessarily. The average guess of a bunch of people is more accurate than most of the individual people. Voting is a form of boosting, the machine-learning sort where you use a bunch of weak classifiers to make a strong classifier.
      • slg 1 hour ago
        The same thing happens in conversations regarding free speech. Proponents present the status quo as the default natural state that must be argued against rather than a preexisting compromise that can and should be continuously reassessed and tweaked when necessary. There's no clear line where free markets or free speech exist. They are both vague terms used to describe a state that almost no one actually wants to live under unless they like botulism and CSAM.

        And these two issues happen to exist in a feedback loop that I believe will continue to get worse until we change something. A democracy that treats money as speech inherently gives outsized political power to the wealthy who can then use it to enact laws further increasing their wealth, then the cycle intensifies and repeats itself.

        • bombcar 1 hour ago
          "Free" in free markets and free speech always means "my restrictions, which are good and reasonable and fair, and nothing more or less."

          In other words, a useless term.

          • cowlevel 1 hour ago
            An illustrative example to both is Elon Musk.
    • throw0101d 1 hour ago
      > It points out that capitalism is an optimization engine for something. Shareholder value and CEO compensation, mostly.

      That is one interpretation on the purpose of companies (and a relatively recent one):

      * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine

      There are others:

      * “Profits are to business as breathing is to life. Breathing is essential to life, but is not the purpose for living. Similarly, profits are essential for the existence of the corporation, but they are not the reason for its existence.” ― Charles A. O'Reilly, Lead and Disrupt: How to Solve the Innovator's Dilemma, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_A._O%27Reilly_III

      * “On the face of it, shareholder value is the dumbest idea in the world. Shareholder value is a result, not a strategy...your main constituencies are your employees, your customers and your products.”[72] — https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Welch#Politics

      Or going back a few decades (in the US):

      > In 1949 General Foods’ president Clarence Francis told Congress that he had a “three-way responsibility to the American consumer, to our associates in this business, and to the 68,000 [stockholders in General Foods]. We . . . would serve (the company’s) interests badly by shifting the fruits of the enterprise too heavily toward any one of those groups.” Two years later, the president of Standard Oil of New Jersey claimed that managers needed “to conduct the affairs of the enterprise in such a way as to maintain an equitable and working balance among the claims of the various directly interested groups—stockholders, employees, customers, and the public at large.” So widespread were such views that, in 1959, one writer in the Harvard Business Review complained that it was no longer “fashionable for the corporation to take gleeful pride in making money.” Instead, he complained, it was typical “for the corporation to show that it is a great innovator; more specifically, a great public benefactor; and, very particularly, that it exists ‘to serve the public’.”

      * https://law.temple.edu/10q/purpose-corporation-brief-history...

      Or back further:

      > American corporate law has long drawn a bright line between for-profit and non-profit corporations. In recent years, hybrid or social enterprises have increasingly put this bright-line distinction to the test. This Article asks what we can learn about the purpose of the American business corporation by examining its history and development in the United States in its formative period from roughly 1780-1860. This brief history of corporate purpose suggests that the duty to maximize profits in the for-profit corporation is a relatively recent development. Historically, the American business corporation grew out of an earlier form of corporation that was neither for-profit nor nonprofit in today’s parlance but rather, served a multitude of municipal, religious, charitable, educational, and eventually business purposes in early nineteenth-century New England. The purposes of early American business corporations—rather than maximization of profit to private shareholders— were often overtly public, involving development of local transportation, finance, and other much-needed economic infrastructure. With the rise of factory-based manufacturing, railroads, and other capital-intensive industries in the middle decades of the nineteenth century and the advent of general incorporation statutes, the purpose of the American business corporation shifted fundamentally from public to private. By 1860, the stage was set for the modern firm.

      * https://repository.law.umich.edu/mbelr/vol9/iss1/2/

    • LPisGood 3 hours ago
      I don’t think capitalism is an optimization machine for CEO compensation. I think it is just for shareholder value; if shareholders thought they could pay a CEO less they would in a heartbeat.
      • bombcar 1 hour ago
        Shareholders barely exist anymore; everything is owned by faceless mechanized mutual funds that always vote in lock-step with the company.
        • cowlevel 1 hour ago
          Those are the shareholders. They receive the value.
      • ZnerflBerp 3 hours ago
        But the principal agent problem between shareholders and CEO is substantial.
      • thaumasiotes 2 hours ago
        > I don’t think capitalism is an optimization machine for CEO compensation. I think it is just for shareholder value

        When you say "capitalism", what do you mean? How would you determine whether any given phenomenon was or wasn't "capitalism"?

        • lordnacho 2 hours ago
          I think of it as a layman's term that means "the way our economic system works".

          It's vague because non-economists generally don't have the specific descriptive words to talk about the economy.

        • pessimizer 2 hours ago
          Why don't you say what you, yourself, think people mean when they use that very common word, and ask this person if they understand it the same way, or if they do not, what the differences are?

          Asking people to put a bunch of work in that you're just going to dismiss with a no true scotsman is rude. I'm not saying that you're doing that, but it sure looks like you're doing that.

          • thaumasiotes 2 hours ago
            I've been pretty open about this in the past. I think there are two-ish common ways to use the word "capitalism". One way, very broadly defined, is to have some principles in mind that define a "capitalist" economy. I'm not going to elaborate further because I don't think it's relevant here.

            The other way is to use "capitalism" to mean "anything that happens in the United States". (And I'll note that lordnacho has provided exactly that definition in a sibling comment to yours.) This is incredibly stupid and effectively prevents any useful discussion. I'm pretty sure it's what's happening here. But under this definition, "capitalism" can have no tendencies, results, or other characteristics. It could mean anything. The exact same set of policies could be "capitalism" one day and the opposite of "capitalism" the next.

            > Asking people to put a bunch of work in that you're just going to dismiss with a no true scotsman is rude. I'm not saying that you're doing that, but it sure looks like you're doing that.

            When I ask this question, I'm satisfied with any definition of "capitalism" that can be applied to policies, laws, or what have you without reference to which country has implemented those policies/laws/etc.

    • baggy_trough 3 hours ago
      The market starts as a natural phenomenon of voluntary trade. Various usually counterproductive strictures are then layered on top.
      • m-ee 16 minutes ago
        The book Debt the first 5000 years spends many pages debunking this idea. Trade arises naturally, the market as we know it is almost always put in place by a government typically to support it's military logistics system.
      • tmoertel 3 hours ago
        > The market is a natural phenomenon of voluntary trade.

        But the market requires oversight to ensure that you have meaningful choices. Otherwise, monopolies and corruption will work to remove your preferred options, forcing you to pay rents.

        • matthest 2 hours ago
          Depends on how low the barriers of competition are. Restaurants have been capitalist markets for hundreds of years and have never devolved into monopolies, even though they exist under relatively little oversight. Because the level of competition is so high.

          This is also true of a wide variety of small businesses.

          More often than we think, monopolies arise out of well-meaning legislation that ends up restricting competition, resulting in oligopoly/monopoly

          • phreeza 2 hours ago
            I don't know about the restaurants having little oversight. Laws regulating restaurants are also as old as time, they are literally in the Code of Hammurabi!

            "If a tavern-keeper does not accept grain according to gross weight in payment of drink, but takes money, and the price of the drink is less than that of the grain, she shall be convicted and thrown into the water."

            • anthuswilliams 1 hour ago
              This isn't really what we would think of as a restaurant regulation, for what it's worth. Tavern keepers were informal bankers and commodity exchanges who extended credit and could manipulate the exchange rate between grain and silver. This law is more similar to a banking or exchange regulation.
          • derektank 2 hours ago
            Sure, but it sounds like you would acknowledge natural monopolies do also exist, which gets us back to the problem of creating rules for the marketplace
          • awesome_dude 1 hour ago
            Almost all of the regulations we have around food are because "restaurants" and "food providers" have put profits ahead of quality - adding adulterants to their products that have been harmful to human health, or lacking the cleaning/hygiene required - do you NEED to experience typhoid to understand why we have public health systems?
          • cowlevel 1 hour ago
            Different markets are different. Restaurants are not social media companies. Social media companies are not restaurants. Neither is Exxon-Mobil. Facts about one market barely affect another.
      • phreeza 3 hours ago
        "Voluntary trade" is just kicking the can down the road imo, it doesn't exist without some sort of rules being enforced around it.
        • unrented7977 3 hours ago
          Markets arise naturally from barter systems.
          • dagss 2 hours ago
            Any context where there is barter, there is also a system of holding each other accountable and consequences of actions.

            It can be informal, like "if you sell me poisonous food and I die you know that my relatives will track you down and kill you or someone close to you". But it is there and part of what makes even bartering possible.

          • cowlevel 1 hour ago
            A lot of things naturally arise from barter systems. How do you delineate things that naturally arise and are free trade, from things that naturally arise and aren't free trade? Who's in charge of making the distinction?
          • fleischhauf 2 hours ago
            there is no natural barter system, it used to be a system of given each other favors, the market was a later invention
          • pfdietz 1 hour ago
            Collusion also naturally arises, and must be suppressed.
          • awesome_dude 1 hour ago
            Regulation arises naturally from disreputable markets
            • baggy_trough 1 hour ago
              And usually becomes counterproductive thereafter, due to public choice theory.
              • awesome_dude 1 hour ago
                Citing Public Choice theory - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_choice#Validity_and_eff...

                > Steven Pressman offers a critique of the public choice approach, arguing that public choice fails to explain political behavior in a number of central areas, including politicians’ behavior and voting behavior.[14] In the case of politicians' behavior, the public choice assumption that a politician's utility function is driven by greater political and economic power cannot account for various political phenomena.[19] These include why politicians vote against their constituents' interests, why they advocate for higher taxation, fewer benefits, and smaller government, and why wealthy people seek office.[19]

                > usually becomes counterproductive thereafter,

                There's no doubt that a balance needs to be found between three forces, the consumer, the producer, and the regulator, but it's pure fallacy to claim that regulation in and of itself "becomes counterproductive"

                This is the hard truth:

                1. a market where the producer holds too much power - monopolies, duopolies, etc, consumers are unable to get a "fair" deal

                2. a market where the consumer holds too much power - producers are unable to survive, or are exploited

                3. a market where the regulator holds too much power - stagflation, little incentive for the producer to seek improvements, little choice for the consumer

                NONE of those are automatic, ALL can be fixed by adjusting the level of regulation in the nominated market, adjusting the balance toward one side or the other

                edit: I think, also, that it's clear that the reason regulation is introduced in the first place is that the nominated market is /already/ broken

          • thaumasiotes 2 hours ago
            I don't think that's accurate as a matter of history. My understanding is that noncommercialized societies don't really use barter systems. They use credit systems, where if you need something you ask for it as a favor and you'll have to repay the favor later in a form determined then, not now.
      • ElevenLathe 2 hours ago
        Counterproductive doesn't mean worthless. Better distribution of fewer resources is, at a certain point, desirable contra massive inequality with higher overall wealth. Regulation can also create wealth, it's not impossible. There's no natural law that requires unregulated barter to be even a local optimum.
      • thisoneisreal 2 hours ago
        Fraud and lemon law strictures aren't counterproductive. The FDA isn't counterproductive. "Voluntary trade" reminds me of the idea that "all natural" products are inherently good. Nature (and other people) will commonly engage in toxic, exploitative behavior without intervention.
      • dagss 2 hours ago
        That is simplistic. Without property rights established by laws and monopoly of violence to police and military there is not much market. There is nothing "natural phenomenon" of the formation of modern shareholder companies operating as separate legal entities but modern capitalism is built around it. You can't sell poisonous food without consequences.

        Any of those you would call counterproductive?

        A market is a human invention and construction, unless you are talking about a kindergarten version of it that is so simplified it borders to parody.

      • pessimizer 2 hours ago
        No, markets (and property itself) are constructed by imposition of rules on trade by an overarching authority. They do not grow from the ground.

        Nature only recognizes possession, not property. No agreements can be made to trade (or even to hold) without a disinterested authority to enforce them.

        The disinterested authority is one that is rewarded by the overall healthy functioning of that particular market, often by taking a cut of every transaction. The rules of that market are whatever rules that authority chooses to enforce, which will be optimized for the benefit of the authority.

        So the order is wrong. First a market is created, then voluntary trades are made under its authority. Previous to the market, people hold what they're willing to fight to have (or keep), and anything that resembles a "voluntary trade" is accidental.

        For example, someone might be willing to leave something behind in order to grab something else, and they might find a counterparty who will leave the thing to be grabbed and take the thing left behind; but that doesn't make a market. If one is far more powerful than the other, they don't have to consider leaving anything behind in order to take what they want. Everything is already theirs, and the other has to settle for discards. Not coincidentally, this resembles capitalism in practice.

        • anubistheta 2 hours ago
          > No agreements can be made to trade (or even to hold) without a disinterested authority to enforce them.

          That's objectively false. Mutually beneficial agreements exist. Countries engage in trades and agreements and there is no party to enforce them.

          • cowlevel 1 hour ago
            They also break those agreements as often as they can get away with. Occasionally they miscalculate.
  • michalsustr 2 hours ago
    It’s a long article, and the most important idea is buried towards the end:

    > That’s where I come back to the idea of mechanism design as reverse game theory. Rather than asking ourselves the rules of the game we are now playing, it calls us to ask “What game ought we to be playing?” And that question leads me imperatively to my answer: “The game of human flourishing.”

    I wholeheartedly agree: we should think way harder about what we want humanity to optimize for collectively, rather than keeping it haphazard.

    The current economic system is built on the idea of ‘shareholder value maximisation’, which, in a finite world, will ultimately become simply ‘value extraction’. With AI, we’ve built an automated value extractor, which can extract value even faster than was done before. Because of that, the old model can no longer work for improving human flourishing — in a finite world, it will inevitably lead to economic accumulation by few entities, throttling the economic flow.

    • EdwardDiego 1 hour ago
      > shareholder value maximisation

      I agree, when I was taking governances courses via the local Institute of Directors, they repeatedly emphasised that this is the primary task of corporate boards.

      One example they gave was - if your company is intending to develop a new line of business or product with an expected return on investment of 20%, and has the cash on hand to fund it, you should instead use that cash to issue a dividend or buy back stock, and then borrow money at a rate <20% to develop that line of business instead, as this delivers the best value to shareholders.

      I was a little gobsmacked at that, as while I understand the logic, they didn't really discuss the risk of what happens if that expected return doesn't eventuate.

    • bawolff 26 minutes ago
      Well does anyone have an answer to how we should optimize instead?

      Much of philosophy throughout history has dealt with this question, but i dont know if anyone has come to a compelling conclusion.

      Capitalism's claim to fame is that practically speaking it seems to make the average person richer (at the cost of inequality and a lot of externalities). In the cold war, communists might have been more equal, but the average person was still probably better off in the west.

    • proc0 33 minutes ago
      The reason this is naive is because human flourishing is not free. Resources are not infinite. If we were to reach some theoretical utopia at some point the flourishing reaches a limit, and the problem repeats itself. Population would explode, more resources would be needed, etc.

      This could even be biological. The humans that didn't strive to compete are the losers of natural selection. It's Nieztche, but I think there's something there because we can clearly see there is no chance of a utopia if we're honest about the human condition.

  • CoolestBeans 3 hours ago
    I don't disagree with anything O'Reilly is saying but lets also call out the proximate cause which is that ZIRP era allowed these companies to grow to grotesque proportions and incentivized upstarts to shoot big in green fields rather than compete in known markets. Now interest rates are back and tech companies are cannibalizing their core competencies on the back of AI. Will markets begin slapping wrists for reckless spending and will upstarts see weakness and stab at exposed bellies? No guarantee they will but it is more possible than analysts are realizing.
    • consensus1 2 hours ago
      Startups are about the least leveraged businesses out there and software, pre AI, was one of the least capital intense. This is not a matter of interest rates. The reason we don't see as many shots at greenfields now is because the simple ones are already taken.
      • whateveracct 2 hours ago
        it's not about startups taking loans

        it's that the cost of money was cheap so the opportunity cost of investing in a startup was cheaper

        when you can get a decent rate for free, you're less interested in chasing unicorns

        • consensus1 2 hours ago
          If you want to claim that people are going into investment grade instead of high yield credit because of this, then that would be believable, but capital allocated to VC funds is chasing bigger returns and is not going to be distracted by 5% on the 10Y. VCs have not tightened up and are throwing money at anything AI related just like they were at anything "blockchain" a few years ago.
          • caminante 1 hour ago
            IMHO, you're overlooking a key point.

            Startups not relying on debt doesn't dismiss how ZIRP still affected their Cost of Equity or valuations from investors using debt or CAPM.

            You're now referring to the consolidation into mega VC funds that can chase AI / compute. Anecdotally, I don't know any AI startups saying they're facing less scrutiny. People are still trying to negotiate valuations for firms with a fraction of headcount.

          • cowlevel 1 hour ago
            Who funds the VCs? What's the overall return rate of VCs? Think it's below or above 5%?
      • CoolestBeans 1 hour ago
        It isn't about startups taking loans. It is about where LPs and private equity want to place their money, whether potential customers can stomach prices, and how long a company can afford to grow before having to show profit. This is why central bank policy is so pored over. Interest rates are input costs for the entire economy and set the temperature everywhere. I agree that interest rates are not the entire story though and I am not certain they will do the damage necessary to bring Silicon Valley back in line.
    • smallmancontrov 2 hours ago
      No, monetary policy isn't responsible for enshittification. Cheap money reduces pressure to enshittify (investors more willing to delay returns) and increases pressure to not-enshittify (competition is easier to capitalize), if anything, though it's certainly not a sustainable lever to achieve that.

      No, at its core enshittification is just capitalism in the absence of consumer bargaining power. Every year, companies alter the deal and it gets a bit worse for consumers and a bit better for shareholders. Consumer protection is asleep at the wheel, antitrust is shot dead at the wheel (thanks Ronald Reagan and Robert Bork), and the hands-off approach enters its Nth year of doing what you expect it to do if you are smart and the opposite of what you expect if you are the opposite of smart.

      • awesome_dude 2 hours ago
        The standard operating model for some time has been for investors/VCs to "buy" the market - pour money into a venture, that is charging below cost for its services/wares (Uber, for example)

        At some point a return is expected, and the only ways to achieve that is by either increasing what is being charged or reducing what is being given away/sold

        The only other way that i can think about was the previous operating model - sell to a massive company that will try and use it as a feature add to their existing portfolio (FAANG/IBM/Microsoft) but even they need to show a ROI (LinkedIn is the best example of this)

  • jansport123 3 hours ago
    The yuppies who dominated wallstreet in the 80s started streaming to SV. Now we have “VC influencers” - they sit around in a podcast style and talk endless nonsense about the “future” in a very self serving way. I don’t know if SV ever had integrity but these days it seems thinner than ever.
    • cowlevel 1 hour ago
      Most of them are part of a cult known as TESCREAL. Most of the influencing you're talking about is in-group shibboleths.
      • matltc 1 hour ago
        > TESCREAL

        acronym for Transhumanism, Extropianism, Singularitarianism, Cosmism, Rationalism, Effective Altruism, Longtermism

        • cowlevel 1 hour ago
          Indeed.

          Those are several outward-facing facets of the cult, but not the cult itself. Like the blind people calling an elephant a TELBAT for Trunk, Ears, Legs, Back, Ass, Tail. Probably the best handle we'll get on it without actually being inside the cult.

    • consensus1 2 hours ago
      You can find plenty of examples of complete lack of integrity in SV, but I really don't see how that is one of them.
    • alephnerd 2 hours ago
      Not really. Most management, VC, and leadership in tech are ex-Engineers. It takes an engineering mindset to successfully optimize.

      The world for those us who started in the 2010s is much more competitive than it was for the anachronistic minority of hippie types you'd see in SV when growing up (PS - Dario Amodei's parents were similar).

      Since the early 2010s, getting into a target or semi-target CS/ECE/EECS/EE/CE program required having a 1500/2200+ SAT; 12-14 APs; honors societies like NHS & CSF; multiple semi-competitive ECs like Speech&Debate, Sports, Orchestra; and being competitive in Olympiads. Forget CS@Stanford - you won't get into CS@SJSU or UCR without a similar profile now.

      To succeed this requires a deeply competitive, vicious, and tactical personality and mindset.

      Those of us who came out of this background are now leadership (it only takes 10-20 years out of undergrad to reach that position). Either you should be able to compete or you will go the way of the dinosaurs or the Aztec.

      • ks2048 2 hours ago
        > Most management, VC, and leadership in tech are ex-Engineers.

        The engineer in me needs proof for this.

        • alephnerd 2 hours ago
          Go on LinkedIn and see the career history of most C-Suites, VCs, PMs, EMs, and VPs in any major tech company or fund HQed in the US. Especially look for those of us who graduated since 2010 onwards.

          Heck, your undergrad alma mater's CS and ECE program has been a target program for VC analysts, PMs, and engineers on the Engineering Leadership track for over a decade now. And take a look at the trajectory of most of your school's alma maters now in tech leadership, founder, and VC positions.

          Older engineers (who tend to be overrepresented on HN) don't seem to get the mindset shift. HN seems to be dominated by boomers in their late 30s to 50s now (yes, this is what Boomer now means). Y'all sound like the same kinds of older engineers who would complain about your types back in the 2000s.

          • ks2048 1 hour ago
            Please don't tell me to go on LinkedIn :)

            Quick AI question said among VCs: 58% MBAs, 33% engineering or science degree.

            • alephnerd 20 minutes ago
              And what was their degree before they got an MBA - most studied engineering beforehand and worked as engineers for years before going to BSchool.

              Hell, look at your grad school Alma mater's BSchool. The plurality of MBAs at Sloan, as well as across the Charles at HBS, or at Stanford and other M7s are former engineers.

              And you are ignoring Product, Engineering, and Corporate Management as well, where the ex-engineer ratio increases significantly.

              And even in VC, 40% of VCs studied STEM in their undergrad. 35% studied business or Econ in undergrad, and the rest humanities and social sciences [0].

              [0] - https://ilyastrebulaev.substack.com/p/moneyball-for-vcs-how-...

      • watwut 1 hour ago
        > To succeed this requires a deeply competitive, vicious, and tactical personality and mindset.

        That is not an engineer. That is sociopath manager with math skills

        > Those of us who came out of this background are now leadership (it only takes 10-20 years out of undergrad to reach that position).

        Otherwise said, people who went into management, not engineering.

    • qlte 2 hours ago
      Also perplexed by the phenomenon of those AI/"tech" talk shows where the apparent premise is a host interviews their own friends/coinvestors/roommates/etc, so they can agree about how awesome and correct they all are for 60 minutes.
      • sph 2 hours ago
        I get why they exist, I don’t understand who exactly is their audience. Gullible tech people that have just entered the workforce?
    • rglover 1 hour ago
      > I don’t know if SV ever had integrity but these days it seems thinner than ever.

      The consistency of gruel.

  • smath 1 hour ago
    Great article and great discussion here. This is a core topic of our time, up there along with stuff like climate change.

    Here is an honest Q: does this change in behavior (focus on value extraction) make it harder for people genuinely interested in value creation?

    • nilsherzig 1 hour ago
      I think so. Imagine trying to compete with a company which is able to just burn VC money for years and years to capture the marked its in. So you might have the better product (even for your consumers, especially long term) but you just cant compete on price and you will get driven out of that market.
    • cowlevel 1 hour ago
      Yes. Imagine you want to make a website about, say, toilet paper designs and you fill it with high-quality information about toilet paper designs. Your value will rapidly be extracted by 20 different AI companies and 5000 AI slop companies who will set up sites identical to yours but with more ads and better SEO.
  • Murfalo 2 hours ago
    > In my 2005 essay “What Is Web 2.0?” I described how the companies that survived the dotcom bust had all, in one way or another, figured out how to help people navigate the resulting information explosion at scale. As Herbert Simon noted in 1971, an abundance of information leads to a scarcity of attention. In the face of increasing information abundance, he predicted that we would use machines to help us better allocate our time and attention. And so it has transpired: Information has become so abundant that it defies manual curation. Instead, powerful, proprietary algorithmic systems use the data they collect to match users with the answers, news, entertainment, products, applications, and services they seek. Today’s AI is in many ways a continuation of this arc.

    This is something I've been thinking about a lot. For so long our algorithms have been weaponized against ourselves, but it really feels like we are agonizingly close to finally being able to put them to good use... Couldn't come sooner!

    • pessimizer 1 hour ago
      > it really feels like we are agonizingly close to finally being able to put them to good use...

      Not if RAM, CPUs, and intellectual property are captured by colluding oligarchs.

      • matltc 57 minutes ago
        I don't know if compute is a bottleneck for managing context at the individual scale. AI companies have indeed stolen vast amounts of IP for their benefit, but who among us hasn't? Point is we can now access and filter information a lot more efficiently, and though yes, out of the box context management/memory is a walled garden shithole that tends to be detrimental, it can be patched quite easily to whatever one likes.

        I'm excited to see the open memory project the speaker cites, first I've heard of it.

  • 0xcafefood 43 minutes ago
    > AI is the real deal, a transformative technology like the internet. And its leading company, Anthropic, looks to be turning into an actual business with cash flow and profits. But others, even those like OpenAI with enormous revenues, are still dependent on massive additional capital infusions to survive.

    Are Anthropic's financials actually that much stronger than OpenAI's? They continue to rely on massive capital infusions to survive too.

    • TSiege 31 minutes ago
      If they didn’t make massive fixed commitments in compute spend, I don’t think there would be any doubt that anthropic has been a wild success. They have crazy revenue and I don’t think the market for tokens is tapped if they develop the right products which they are.

      That though is their biggest issue now since they’re developing products that directly compete against the companies that sell them compute. They’re taking on gsuite, and imo it’s “if you come for the king you best now miss” kind of moments.

  • joewhale 3 hours ago
    Greed and lack of purpose.
    • musicale 2 hours ago
      > Make number go up.
  • amluto 1 hour ago
    > Likewise, Amazon, which used to call itself the most customer-centric company on earth, now puts sixteen ads and four organic results on a typical search results page. Sometimes, it may take scrolling past three screens of results to reach the first organic search result. And by “the first organic search result,” I mean “the best guess of the company’s smartest algorithms for what the user is actually looking for.” In former times, that was the top result. No more.

    It’s slightly worse. The actual thing the user is looking for is often inserted as a paid ad before the identical organic result.

    • qlte 10 minutes ago
      I started using Walmart+ when it was new during the pandemic and first the first couple years was vastly superior to Amazon for household/pantry type purchases. It was clearly in cash burning mode that couldn't last, but being able to buy a few bottles of hot sauce or something at identical prices as in-store for next day delivery with no order minimum or tip was a fantastic user experience.

      There may have been one or two sponsored results, but in general it was basically a search for product->see it in search results->add to cart->get it next day. Eventually (and predictably) they started using dark patterns and then explicit policy changes to steer towards regular delivery with $30+ minimums, upselling to faster delivery surcharges, etc but the simplicity of being able to get the exact product I'd buy in stores at 1:1 price parity justified paying for another year.

      Now? If you search for any product, you literally have to swipe down multiple pages worth of sponsored search results, much of it 3rd party "marketplace" sellers essentially running a scam with $20 shipping on a 8 dollar bottle of hot sauce. It is absolutely maddening having the marketplace slop sponsored sellers outcompete the entire value proposition of the service: household/grocery items at predictable Walmart prices.

      I'd expected and would continue to put up with more restrictive minimums and such so the economics would work out, but I cancelled auto-renewal entirely because I can't even use the service anymore thanks to the sponsored results spam.

    • cowlevel 1 hour ago
      The company selling that thing is forced (by Amazon) to do that so users can search for it. Amazon doesn't mind since it gets paid more.
  • rr808 1 hour ago
    Fascinating that one of the reasons SV got started was because land was cheap and climate along with low cost of living attracted engineers. Seems the opposite now its the most expensive part of the world to build a company. Sure the talent is there but its just too costly.
  • musicale 3 hours ago
    Bill Gross came up with pay-per-click advertising, and then Google perfected it. And that totally was this new, again, once again, mechanism design, pay-per-click advertising, totally transformative economic mechanism.

    Tim implies this is great, but...

    Advertising on the commercial web led to adtech, which "perfected" surveillance capitalism, which is one of the things he is complaining about.

    Perhaps he felt it was acceptable until "don't be evil" (rather inevitably) started limiting Google's growth (and was therefore abandoned.)

    • noosphr 2 hours ago
      We have adtech because we haven't figured out micro payments.

      If we could make a bitcoin that can scale to a trillion transaction per second with fees of much less than a cent we'd solve most of the problems of internet based capitalism.

      • coderintherye 51 minutes ago
        Visa only does a few thousand transactions per second across its entire network with peaks in the 10s of thousands. The idea that we'd need trillion transactions per second is unfounded.

        There are already plenty of distributed ledgers that can handle existing transaction levels, especially with rollups. The problem is not technological, as the other comment replier noted. The technology is there. It's an economics and demand problem. Most people don't want to pay for the content that ads are serving and often the ads are more profitable than the subscription costs would net the company hosting them.

      • cowlevel 1 hour ago
        We don't have micropayments because most of the things with ads, that would have micro payments, are lemons (as in market for lemons) that are not worth paying for. Imagine Google but you pay $0.001 per result you click on, would you even bother using it? No because most of them are just seoslop.
        • grogenaut 14 minutes ago
          also back at the time where it was actually tenable companies would price their content at $.27 - $4 for an article but were happy go get $4 per thousand ad impressions.

          some of this is inflexiibility of payment systems, some if payment fraud and some is inability to set a tenable price.

    • TheOtherHobbes 2 hours ago
      Surveillance capitalism invested heavily to create what's called adtech. Writers like Evgeny Morozov have done a good job of covering this.

      Everything is monitored and compiled through telemetry - not just pages viewed, cookies tracked, and purchases made, but psychological player profiling in many games, and of course interest profiles on social media.

  • caminante 2 hours ago
    To me, this is the money quote:

    >Silicon Valley has gotten addicted to value capture without value creation. Think about it: 75 to 80% of IPOs are for companies without any profits. Add in acquisitions of pre-IPO companies and the numbers are likely even worse. It’s like a horse race where bettors can collect their winnings when the horse has rounded the first or second turn.

  • bix6 3 hours ago
    Fantastic read thank you
  • soundworlds 1 hour ago
    One point I always see missed: the world wide web was released as an open protocol, and this did not come from Silicon Valley, but CERN in Europe.

    I'm not saying that Silicon Valley is inherently bad, but the game there has always been venture capital and proprietary productization. And somehow Silicon Valley gets the credit for the Open Internet that we all miss.

    This is not to shame any one culture, but it is super important that we are accurate about which environments incentivize human-flourishing-tech.

  • smath 2 hours ago
    In a way, our current free-market capitalist system solves a distributed optimization problem, using prices as a signal. It is distributed because each unit (person, business) is free to make its own decision. The profit motive is useful as a signal for optimization. But it is not necessary optimal; I believe it is a proxy for something else, namely overall human welfare, and good functioning of society, but since we cannot easily measure or agree on these other things, we use price. Whenever we use a proxy to optimize a different objective, it is possible to 'overfit' [0], i.e. get worse on the real objective. I feel we will see the emergence of other, maybe better, systems, in our lifetime. Its good to see people are thinking along these lines [1]

    [0] https://sohl-dickstein.github.io/2022/11/06/strong-Goodhart....

    [1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12207456/

    • anubistheta 1 hour ago
      The system doesn't really solve for anything. Each individual person does so. Price isn't utility. It's just the costs. We two people engage in a trade, both sides profit. A business can only profit if it can supply things at a cost less than people's utility. For a price X, the company's utility is X-Y, and my utility is X+Z. We make the exchange and both profit by it. Overall, we are Y+Z better off. For each person, that Z can be anything. For you, it could include the total impact on human welfare. There's no central optimization being done as each person is optimizing their own function. That's a mistake that far too many people make.
      • cowlevel 1 hour ago
        You are claiming that because trees exist, recognizing a forest is a mistake people make.
  • augment_me 2 hours ago
    Great breakdown of the problem, but we get no viable path to a solution, and IMO where are some misguided comparisons.

    1) When Unix was made the hardware gap between Bell Labs and a uni comp-sci dept was a single minicomputer. Bell Labs was also legally barred from commercializing it due to the 1956 AT&T Antitrust Consent Decree. Today the frontier AI requires gigawatt-scale data centers costing a couple of tens of billions of dollars. No open software protocols or MCP servers can decentralize a market when the underlying compute substrate in itself is an industrial monopoly.

    2) The author argues that governance fails unless we reprogram the corporate incentive machine, yet he expects AI labs to voluntarily build open ecosystems inside this capitalist market he just proved is inescapable with the shareholder arguments. Even if every lab agrees that displacing consumers ruins the macroeconomy, any lab that sacrifices margins for "human flourishing" will just be out-competed.

    ---

    Like, he is against government regulations, but at the same time fails to see that Bell Labs would have probably commercialized UNIX if it was not forced to not do so by the antitrust law. So the previous solution is ignored, and the new solution 'reprogram the machine' has no plan or suggestion on how to do it.

    • mrdependable 1 hour ago
      Where did he say he is against government regulation? His suggested solution was to change the mechanisms so they incentivize a better outcome. I don’t see how that would be possible without government regulation.
  • mrdependable 1 hour ago
    This really put into words why these AI companies piss me off so much.
  • jameskilton 3 hours ago
    The pursuit of money and power.
  • mentalgear 3 hours ago
    Greed, quasi-monopolies, megalomaniacs, fascists: Basically what you get through out history if a society allows for too much power getting concentrated in the hands of a few. And it never ends well for society.
  • paulstovell 1 hour ago
    He mentions the book Incorruptible, which the book I got the most value from this year. I am in the midst of removing this corruption from my own company and the results are amazing. Counterintuitively, it’s also a better result for my investors, even though the standard VC company playbook is what causes most of the corruption in the first place.
  • segmondy 2 hours ago
    Nothing, it's the same SV. It's just time that has changed.
  • bluegatty 1 hour ago
    Yes, supportive of this, but TBC there's at least a healthy degree of value creation going on. Sometimes, even goofy people we 'do not like' are even creating a lot of value.

    I'm not positive on the Uber makers, and Uber broke a lot of rules - but - even then - Uber is still kind of a good operational innovation.

    At the very same time Uber was 'bad' for breaking some civic codes, they were 'good' for disrupting very gold and entrenched systems that needed some competition.

    I don't think it's a 'paradox' it's just the reality of our complicated systems.

    " It’s in the overriding economic incentives of today’s shareholder capitalism. "

    It's been that way forever.

    Columbus was more of a Capitalist than explorer. When he got out from under the thumb of 'regulations' he plundered.

    There were rules against putting people into slavery and all sorts of conventions around serfdom etc. - he 'got outside of that where the rules did not apply' and when those guys starting making $, more powerful interests wanted in on the action. Until we had wars to re-instate social conventions and then some.

  • BrenBarn 42 minutes ago
    This article suffers from "Hacker News syndrome", viz., the tendency to describe things as problems with tech when they are problems with society as a whole. The rent-seeking, inequality, warped incentives, and "living in different worlds" problems described here pervade the whole economy. They are perhaps most obvious in tech, but they are everywhere.

    That said, the article lays out the problem pretty well. In particular this:

    > We need to tear down and rebuild that machine, reprogramming it so that human flourishing, not corporate profit, becomes its goal.

    . . . acknowledges that improving things requires change that is in some degree "destructive", in that it involves undoing things that have been done and tearing out things that are already in place. This is something that is often missed by "institutionalists" and others of their ilk. We cannot make things better with just more good; we need less harm.

    > The betting economy, within reason, is a good thing. Speculative bets on the future are how we fund innovation and build infrastructure ahead of the prosperity it will bring.

    This is maybe barely true, but I think it's much less true than is implied here. Speculative bets are not a good thing. Solid bets are a good thing. It's possible that some degree of speculation is a useful spice to be sprinkled into the economy, but if so it's much, much, less, like maybe 1000 or 100,000 times less, than what we have now.

    The other issue is that without constant attention to inequality, even a small level of speculation quickly spirals out of control, because those whose speculative bets pay off now have an enormous amount of spare wealth with which to bet even more speculatively. This leads to a distorted economy which is responsive only to the speculations of a tiny class of people who got lucky with their previous bets. (They got lucky. They did not "succeed". They got lucky. This is another problem with how we view it.) This is the situation we're in now, in that the wealth inflating these bubbles is being pumped in by people who are already rich.

    The distinction O'Reilly makes between the "operating economy" and the "betting economy" is a great one. Our goal should be to stifle the latter virtually out of existence. The vast majority of economic activity and growth should be in the operating economy.

    • jgord 11 minutes ago
      I end to agree .. inequality has increased since the 80s, as seen in things like median house price / median salary

      Recently this is accelerated by the AI boom : hyperscalars buying up GPUs and RAM and SSDs has driven the price of PC components way up - a practical if limited example of inequality stealing resources from the middle of the economy, which people like Garys Economics, Paul Krugman, Piketty, Gabriel Zucman talk about. [ The ultra wealthy outcompete the less so in competing for finite resources. ]

      Two ways to mitigate this - increase growth rate of the real economy, through things like tech innovation productivity gains such as cheaper cleaner energy .. or limit the growth rate of rich money by taxing uber-wealth and using it for common good projects - bridges, healthcare, education / science research.

      The trajectory of LLM AI currently seems to be aligned with increasing inequality, not human flourishing. Id be less certain of this if for example Google and Anthropic and OpenAI committed to only renewable energy to drive their new datacenters.

  • culebron21 3 hours ago
    I haven't finished reading, but O'Reilly is probably the best man to tell about this.
  • moof11 33 minutes ago
    Silicon Valley should be nuked. Vaporizing those freaks could save this country!
  • aorloff 2 hours ago
    > As Herbert Simon noted in 1971, an abundance of information leads to a scarcity of attention.

    We are now about 15 years past when most Americans could be expected to have a smartphone, and nearly every kind of long form content is having a little trouble breathing like dinosaurs after a giant meteor. The entire movie industry appears broken and is basically taking its content from youtubers (a refreshing update to a long suffering dinosaur), only a very few (ie: none) musicians can make a living from selling records, and with the exception of perhaps you folks on hacker news, few people read books.

    • TheOtherHobbes 2 hours ago
      Not quite.

      People are still reading books and selling records, but discovery has become vastly more difficult, marketing hustle takes as much effort as "content creation", payment rates have dropped, and the economic feedback loop means that rich, complex, non-obvious art is much less likely to be discovered and supported.

      Previous periods of oligarchy at least included some element of philanthropy. The 0.1% built libraries and concert halls, funded universities and sometimes schools, commissioned art and music, and generally made some effort to leave a positive legacy - even if only for PR reasons.

      The current oligarchy appears to have no interests beyond selfishness, self-indulgence, and a narcissism of aggressive contempt for the 99%.

      • TFNA 52 minutes ago
        Readership is cratering even among demographics that were historically bookish and have access to excellent libraries (so it isn't a discovery issue). The biggest counterexample to the trend is romance and romantasy, and some YA stuff, but that is a poor substitute for the whole canon of literature.
  • sno6 48 minutes ago
    The irony is not lost on me that this post makes a good 'how to raise capital in 2026' guide.
  • ks2048 2 hours ago
    Traditional greed and corruption covers a lot, but it seems the new generation has something even more sinister - “we need all the money and power or else baddies (Chinese, robots, etc) will take over.”
    • alephnerd 2 hours ago
      We live in a more competitive world today. Either you keep up or you can nope out.
      • cowlevel 1 hour ago
        But what is the competition? When people say the Chinese will beat us... at what? They don't mean quality of life. They mean at the capitalist game.
      • antonvs 40 minutes ago
        Or, we can work to change the unfair and broken rules that turn “more competitive” into “winner takes all”.
  • blfr 3 hours ago
    So are AI companies unprofitable money furnaces with no moat or are they extracting robber baron rents? They surely cannot be both.
    • zbentley 2 hours ago
      Depending on what you mean by "AI company" (which is an extremely ambiguous term that deserves a pretty rigorous definition before we talk about economics), it absolutely can be both.

      Hell, it can be both within a single company. A commercial airline is both a famously terribly unprofitable venture and one that employs insane rent-seeking tactics (premium tiers, seat shrinkage) routinely. Hospitals and other healthcare industry participants are the same way: massive cost collapse leads to businesses closing and PE buyouts, at the same time as parasitic rent-seeking ("Office Visit" ICD codes, anyone?).

      The recipe is usually: extremely inelastic demand/captive audiences for a service means that competition-based pricing assumptions pretty much immediately lead to rent-seeking and/or monopolistic behavior, and at the same time the margin pressure on the business might be intense.

      Or, even more briefly: slim or negative margins don't always indicate a pareto optimum or the presence of competition. Sometimes, that just means that a competition/market-based pricing model isn't a good fit for a given industry.

    • mrdependable 1 hour ago
      I think his point is that it would have been better if the AI labs made their money without the eye watering amounts of investment. The building of the technology should be rewarded, but the amount of investment is there to make sure no one else can profit off it in the future.
    • walt_grata 3 hours ago
      The business can be the former while the executives and investors are the later in our current system with wall street.
      • consensus1 2 hours ago
        But in reality they are not. Tech companies have a more favorable ownership split to founders and employees vs investors than any other major industry.
      • ares623 2 hours ago
        Exactly. At the end of the day, only a few people need to make ungodly amounts of money. The rest is confetti.
    • cowlevel 1 hour ago
      Why not both? They're stealing everything from everyone and still losing money.
  • mrworld 50 minutes ago
    Greed happened. When both the investors and the founders are focused on short term money over product, it becomes like inbreeding. People and products get less inventive, the pool gets less diverse, everything stalls out until it’s a shit soup. They optimise for an algorithm of rapid acquisition, only slightly different from big players but close enough to catch their eye. Look at me! I’m exactly like you but slightly better!
  • cheesecompiler 3 hours ago
    Curious how people here might justify the current reality.
    • ares623 2 hours ago
      I. HATE. YAML. I WOULD BURN MY PARENTS RETIREMENT FUNDS IF IT MEANS I NEVER HAVE TO DEAL WITH IT EVER AGAIN.

      - the average tech bro

  • mistrial9 53 minutes ago
    after well-earned fortunes in Book Publishing headed his way in the 1990s, Tim O’Reilly was regularly mocked by serious people behind closed doors for his messianic ego and bold takes from the armchair. Yet some of those serious people included those that built and executed a modern surveillance state.

    My personal opinion is that this self-important fool has a podium at a critical time and is worth listening to, but judge for yourself

  • RomanPushkin 2 hours ago
    Locals failed it. They always vote against building nice high-rise affordable housing. Tech bros drive insane money to SV. They also suffer paying insane rents to local landlords who exploit the local laws. All others suffer because landlords don't want to go to work every day like everyone else. If we build 500 high-rise buildings, we'll have happy kids, families, infrastructure, low rents, artists back in SF.
  • profsummergig 2 hours ago
    SV has done enough for the world. It's time for payday.
  • HeavyStorm 47 minutes ago
    Money happened.
  • newobj 2 hours ago
    the meta became exits instead of out-nerding each other
  • tsunamifury 1 hour ago
    Let the market be free is what the guy with his hand on the Ouija board says to trick you into believing his movements are just mysterious outcomes.
  • GlacierFox 3 hours ago
    It went from an all-round aspirational place to work to something you'd rather keep to yourself depending on the audience. Sort of like if you work for Raytheon.
    • georgemcbay 30 minutes ago
      > It went from an all-round aspirational place to work to something you'd rather keep to yourself depending on the audience. Sort of like if you work for Raytheon.

      And tech is probably in a worse position than Raytheon in terms of receptive audience by the numbers.

      There are lots of people on the right that don't have a problem with the military industrial complex.

      But pretty much everyone across the political spectrum distrusts the tech industry these days.

  • api 3 hours ago
    Value extraction is easier if you can do it.

    I think you can make a base thermodynamic argument. Value creation means climbing hard up against entropy. It means searching large solution spaces. It means risk with unknown payoff.

    A rough analogy would be drilling a gas or oil well versus replicating what plants do with solar panels or harnessing atomic energy directly. Those are way harder than burning what was already deposited at high concentration. An imperfect but not totally wrong comparison I think.

    Value extraction just requires that you identify value already there and make a plan to get and store or monetize it.

    A lot of the debate over the merit of capitalism would be clearer if we made a hard distinction between value creating capitalism and value extracting capitalism. The latter is closer to imperial conquest or raiding the next village but with many more steps and in the modern world often without direct force.

    The most common way to sack the populace today is trickery and exploitation of the human dopamine system. Financial con games rank highly too.

    Value creating capitalism gave us modernity and a higher standard of living than Pharaohs. Raiding and conquest was what humans were jacking off doing for all the preceding 100k+ years when standard of living barely moved for most people.

  • leoc 2 hours ago
    The statements about shareholder capitalism are a bit strange as an explanation of what happened to Google. As O'Reilly surely knows, thanks to Google's, then Alphabet's, dual-class ownership structure Page and Brin have a majority of the voting rights over Alphabet. Furthermore Google's original IPO prospectus https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1288776/000119312504... seems to have given its shareholders a pretty clear warning of what to expect:

    > Google is not a conventional company. Eric, Sergey and I intend to operate Google differently, applying the values it has developed as a private company to its future as a public company. Our mission and business description are available in the rest of the prospectus; we encourage you to carefully read this information. We will optimize for the long term rather than trying to produce smooth earnings for each quarter. We will support selected high-risk, high-reward projects and manage our portfolio of projects. We will run the company collaboratively with Eric, our CEO, as a team of three. We are conscious of our duty as fiduciaries for our shareholders, and we will fulfill those responsibilities. We will continue to attract creative, committed new employees, and we will welcome support from new shareholders. We will live up to our “don’t be evil” principle by keeping user trust and not accepting payment for search results. We have a dual-class structure that is biased toward stability and independence and that requires investors to bet on the team, especially Sergey and me.

    IANAL, but between this and that it seems fairly unlikely that the threat of shareholder lawsuits forced Page and Brin's hand into making Google's behaviour more extractive, and quite certain that the threat of being outvoted didn't. In that case, it seems the problem (at least before the arrival of ChatGPT, after which LLMs really did present a serious threat to Google's business) wasn't the logic of capitalism but one of personal moral decline on the part of Page and Brin. That in turn probably has at least some connection with the recent trend of SV bigwigs turning into frothing far-right lunatics, which also doesn't seem to have been fully justified by the pursuit of shareholder value.

    In fact the trend now is for people who are sick of tech CEOs playing at overlord to call for the end of dual-class shareholdings. Unfortunately it's not clear how great an answer that is either. For one thing, while dual-class structure obviously didn't stop the rot at Google indefinitely, it's far from clear that things would have gone better, rather than worse, if Google's/Alphabet's leadership have been under the cosh of shareholders eyeing quarterly results. Relying on Page and Brin's good intentions may in fact have been the less-bad option for society at large. Another is that a number of the seemingly-untouchable titans don't in fact have formal majority control, at least not over all of their companies. Musk doesn't seem to have anything like majority voting control over Tesla, for instance.

  • mistic92 2 hours ago
    Money happened
  • musicale 3 hours ago
    > We got there the slow way, through steady organic growth. That is quite anathema to the rush to the top of whatever appears to be the latest hill that seems to characterize Silicon Valley today

    "Today" being the last 35 years at least...

  • mindwok 1 hour ago
    Brilliantly written article and the best articulation of what's wrong and what we can do about it.

    There's too much discourse on billionaires and greed, and not enough about the rules of the game. We can't make Elon Musk a better person. We can change the rules of the game, and we should push our ourselves and our governments to do so.

    • matltc 40 minutes ago
      This talk resonated with me because I think what people mean when they say late-stage capitalism is the state we are in today was inevitable given the rules of the game (maximize shareholder return) and the players (very large corporations, the "slow ais") are on pursuit of that goal at all cost.

      Yes, musk is a supervillain personality who is easy to dunk on, but he is just doing exactly what the game would have him do. He is a point in a field that responds to external forces according to these laws, and since it is found to be a winning strategy, other players respond accordingly, either emulating or countering it. Viewed through this lens, it is difficult to envision the K-shaped economy trend reversing without changing the rules of the game.

    • moof11 31 minutes ago
      > We can change the rules of the game

      Go ahead, try... I'll be waiting.

  • musicale 2 hours ago
    > [Musk] was getting this incredible lift from the fact that people were giving him credit for 600 years of future profits

    P/E ratio of 600 seems crazy unless the assets balance it out somehow.

    • actionfromafar 13 minutes ago
      Still fairly bold to bet that a ket head won't mess things up too badly along the way.
  • nakedrobot2 2 hours ago
    I highly recommend the book "Incorruptible" by Eric Ries. It is about how to build companies that don't become enshittified (financially, or product-wise) and it comes to a similar conclusion: the mission needs to be about "human flourishing". A great book.
  • pjmlp 28 minutes ago
    Late stage capitalism, is what happened.
  • thom 1 hour ago
    I know how tedious it sounds when someone says Marx was right, but idealistic Silicon Valley 'hackers' were always just a reserve army of labour for the capital class.
  • riazrizvi 1 hour ago
    It's helpful to highlight issues. But I'd say the best focus is achieved by pointing the blame at the consumer who has allowed themself to be gamed out of their intentional capacity by other ppl's random agendas. If we don't design the environment we want to live in using our assets we end up with a random environment.

    Sure there are secondary forces, intentionally predatory, analyzing our behavior and playing us, but the amount of control we exercise in our own proximity is insurmountable in a free society.

    • kubb 1 hour ago
      When has blaming the consumer ever solved anything?
      • cowlevel 1 hour ago
        When the goal is to not fix the problem.
  • sl0wbrainRot 3 hours ago
    [flagged]